Closs the cases, not solve. It's good that police can't convict innocent people as easily anymore.
Closs the cases, not solve. It's good that police can't convict innocent people as easily anymore.
If we release someone because there’s a 1 in 200 chance they’re not guilty, so be it. That’s not suggesting we release people where that chance is 0 in 200.
The innocent person is worth dozens, but not scores? And certainly “criminals” is a quite broad category - “dozens of shoplifters” but not “scores of pedophiles”?
Curious if that was intentional and where the line actually is.
Otherwise it seems you’re just expressing a cost-free emotional sentiment. In the world of policy with real consequences (violent crime) on real people (also at times innocent), the sentiment gives very little guidance, really only the barest start of an inquiry.
Let’s say thousands of murderers going free that otherwise wouldn’t results in one person dying that otherwise wouldn’t.
Is one person unjustly dying with zero chance of resurrection better than one innocent person going to prison with a non-zero chance of exoneration?
This assumes 100% chance of being murdered in the first place which isn't true.
If you put an innocent person I'm prison, they definitely suffer for no reason. If a guilty person goes free, they might commit another crime.
Now, it's true that there is a class of person who meets this description, but we don't call them "murderers". We call them "serial killers", and they're incredibly rare.
Decades of propaganda (some subtle, some overt) has put this notion of "once a murderer, always a murderer" into our collective consciousness, but in the vast majority of cases, that's not true at all. Almost everyone who commits murder has some clear, specific reason to do it at the time, and we would be much better served as a society if we would push harder for addressing those reasons (which, from what I understand, almost all come back to either "proper therapy/anger management" or "providing proper support for every person's basic survival needs") rather than expecting punishment to make people better.