It's not to say we shouldn't help those in need.
It's not to say as a society we're perfect right now.
It's to say that all of the taxpayer funded UBI proposals are morally wrong, and don't work anyway. You can't legislate charity.
It's not to say we shouldn't help those in need.
It's not to say as a society we're perfect right now.
It's to say that all of the taxpayer funded UBI proposals are morally wrong, and don't work anyway. You can't legislate charity.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/10/09/us/california-high-speed-...
There are enumerable examples of fraud and waste coming from gov spending.
So... yes? I _really_ relieve my tax funds are actually feeding people. It's a fact. Unless you're a conspiracy theorist who thinks the government is lying about the numbers and it's actually a slush fund for the CIA or something, but in that case there's not much of a conversation to be had.
I'm glad you are happy about the SNAP program but the US gov has spent so many additional trillions recently which is likely now to cause a recession and high inflation.
> There are poorly run charities that are far more efficient than those programs
Pretty sure they specifically meant social programs, and especially the means-tested ones.
They weren't talking about fraud and waste overall, they were talking specifically about waste in distributing charity.
So whatever point you're trying to make has nothing to do with what I was responding to.
...Except for all of the social programs that are literally just legislated charity?
What do you think TANF (welfare) and SNAP (food stamps) and Medicare and Medicaid and Social Security are...? Heck, what do you think schools and libraries are? Do you think those are all morally wrong as well?
You might as well say you can't legislate a military, or that you can't legislate courts to enforce contracts...
They could be, if one considers the negative morality of non-voluntary, force-backed extraction greater than the positive morality gained by its (partial) redistribution.
Another opinion one could have is that the first part being morally negative makes the whole affair morally wrong, regardless of any positive upside.