More to your point though, sure, it's a praxis vs theory thing. There often will be agreed-upon hierarchies and leadership situations in an anarchist system but the point is they don't get to have coercive power and their authority is consensus-based.
I'm curious about your perspective, because when I've seen this argument before, it seems to be based on a personal literal interpretation of the world anarchism as the negation of hierarchy, as if the etymology of the term is more important of the history of the movement. If you have a deeper insight beyond that, it's worth explaining!
Another definition that might be helpful comes from Noam Chomsky's "What is Anarchism?"
"...anarchism is a tendency in human development that seeks to identify structures of hierarchy, domination, authority, and others that constrain human development. And then it seeks to subject them to a very reasonable challenge: Justify yourself, demonstrate that you're legitimate, and maybe in some special circumstances or conceivably in principle. And if you can't meet that challenge, which is the usual case, the structures should be dismantled, not just dismantled but reconstructed from below."
https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/noam-chomsky-what-is...
Defining it outside theory is an interesting take. But doesn’t praxis eventually require considering theory when a decision has to be made?
Also check out Intentional Communities: https://www.ic.org/
And of course, the IWW is an anarchist organization - I haven't read the entire constitution but skimming it doesn't describe an actual hierarchy, simply a structure and process of delegation and consensus-based decision-making of job duties and organized geographic branches. In fact, they explicitly decry it in favor of grassroots and worker empowerment.
Intentional community development is one of my projects right now, so I appreciate the reference!
I think what you’re describing is something better than anarchism because it has a lot less historical violent baggage associated with it and probably deserves a new name. It might get one if it grew enough. It would probably still involve hierarchies based on consensus and clear limits on scope and time. More arrangements like these would do a lot of good, and I hope we get more of them!