Probability can be used to say something about closed systems like a game of poker using a deck of cards.
If 4 aces have been used I know that there will be no more aces dealt. I can explain why there won't be another ace. And even if magically there was one, we can explain that someone cheated or an extra card was accidentally in the deck.
If 3 aces have been dealt and there are 10 cards left there is statistically a 10% chance of me getting an ace, however I have no way of knowing. The card has already been dealt and I will either get it or I wont.
If I play 10 games will I be getting it 1 time? if I play 100 will i be getting i 10 times? I have no way of knowing.
Now if I learn how to read you and know that you blink more often if you get an ace then I have found an explanation for why I might fold. Not based on statistics but because I can read you. I might still be wrong but I have an explanatory model not based on statistics to play against you, one which I might have to adjust if it turned out to be wrong (ex. you know I know so you change behavior) but at least it's providing me with something more tangible (you give clues I might be able to learn how to interpret)
With the probability it's purely based on blind belief, not substantiated by reality.
Now a deck of card is isolated and not really consequential to society.
But now apply this to open systems economics, weather, climate, elections etc. and you will start to see the problems with assuming there is casual connection when you end up turning that into policy.