"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."
It was shallow because it was (1) low-information*; (2) a cliché; and (3) untied to anything specific about the article.
Such comments are extremely common on the internet and tend to evoke more of the same, which leads to predictable/generic discussions. We're trying to avoid those.
* I know that people sometimes have a lot of information in their heads when they post a comment like that; the problem is that if you don't include that information explicitly in your comment, it's not available to the reader.