"C) there is no difference between saying "There is a 40% chance it happens" and "There is a 60% chance it happens"
AND
"If there is no difference how could it be based on past experience or whatever?"
These are two different propositions and questions.
Past experiences can tell me that if I see dark clouds then it could mean rain.
I could be wrong, I could be right, but I have no way of calculating the probability of that.