Obviously this doesn't take into account political pressures to achieve outcomes other than that hiring the candidate most likely to perform well.
Obviously this doesn't take into account political pressures to achieve outcomes other than that hiring the candidate most likely to perform well.
There's almost certainly a correlation due to success in lacrosse having a lot of crossover with success generally. A young man who plays lacrosse is probably going to be physically healthier than average. It's also a very upper middle class sport, typically played by wealthier types. And children who grew up in wealthier households tend to be ... well, better at everything, really. Hockey is a great indicator of that here in Canada; the equipment is expensive.
I wouldn't be surprised if it's causative, either. Sports may improve cognitive performance, and they tend to teach cooperation and leadership. Plenty of studies suggest it helps academics.
If I felt free to discriminate and if I knew nothing else about a candidate other than whether they had played a physically-demanding and expensive team sport within the last year, I would hire the ones who had over the ones who had not. It'd skew heavily towards fit 20-40 something guys from middle-class backgrounds with college educations. Surprise! Probably what the algorithm picked up, indirectly. Of course, it also blatantly skews white, male, and economically elite.
Now if you mean I'm making an assumption about a candidate, based on nothing more than one weak indicator, well yes. That was the point of my thought experiment. If you only knew whether they played sports, while not a very good indicator, it's better than flipping a coin. Ultimately, that's what hiring is. You have some indicators like education and previous work experience, and you make an assumption based on those facts, none of which align 100% with how they're going to perform at the job you're hiring them for.
That was even more obvious than the sports and cognition fact.
Here's the thing: you're doing the exact thing that caused the problem in the first place. Creating thought experiments and narrating them at length regarding scenarios which are a rarity, given a problem which occurs frequently, in an environment with thousands of other variables.
In a world where we do in fact have better indicators which are still not used, despite being well researched. We have plenty of options remaining before we need to be this nitpicky.
No, it isn't. The "dumb jock" trope is widely known for a reason.
Healthy body is associated with intelligence, and for good reason.
Now only hiring people from OxCam + Ivy + Stanford — that’s the big brain move.
Also not a lot of white guys named Jared playing lacrosse at Oxford or Cambridge (or Peking University).
I bet the lacrosse part is due to the sport being played among academics and then by nobody else. Cue for the AI without intelligence to mark it as an inclusion criterium. Similar to what Golf was a few years ago. A unique property to differentiate academics and non-academics.
IMO it could have an effect on "soft skills". Learning to have an authority push you to beyond your known limits. Working and training within a team to achieve a goal. Learning as a team to face and overcome weaknesses. Social skills that go with it. Humility from dealing with loss. Learning to celebrate victory with dignity.
There's a lot of educational positives that come from team sports. It's certainly not the only place that a person can get those skills, but it's a very common one.
IMO it's one of the biggest benefits of US football simply because the teams are so large, diverse and position groups have different but complimentary jobs.
Just like there are different versions of "good" leaders and "good" workers in any given field, there are different types of "good" in sports.
Similarly, sports has a much more straight-forward rewards system; score a point, prevent the opponent from scoring, immediate result and reward.
For anything technology related, the action => reward system tends to be far more delayed and requires a different approach and type of patience. Whether it's Devops, Programming, Administration, or Support, even if you do everything right, the reward might be delayed or sullied by negative rewards. (e.g., network is never fast enough for users, it's still too complex to use your program, the solution is just not desired by the user)
Again I do understand the premise of your statement, and for some situations I can agree there is crossover, but my experience in hiring for technical positions is that sports participation has been a non-factor at best. Too often, it's been a negative one because the rewards for technology related challenges tend to be very delayed or difficult for the participant to recognize. Success in Technology is very personal and goes beyond the tangible result, and instead is a victory of the self as you grow intellectually and better understand something. This does happen in sports also (you train yourself to recognize openings that maybe didn't exist for you before or you couldn't act on due to physical limitations), but there are other rewards that make sports more compelling.
Tenacity is a strong signal I look for when hiring. Not being afraid to ask for help but being willing to put in the time when it is needed. Sports are open-ended. With school exams you know how many points you can achieve so you know when to stop. In life you don't know how many points can be scored or how much you'd need to train to do so meaning that you need a lot more self-assessment.
I don't use sports as a metric but they seem a lot more valid than many signals I see other reviewers use.
Lacrosse, hockey, football, rugby, etc.
It’s a difference from just developing a skill in terms of mentality.
Within a single sport I’ve always found the offensive line position in football to be unique as well. It’s the only position in sports where your only job is to protect other players.
Amazon should care, due not only to obvious legal risk, but also because they are excluding candidates who otherwise do as well or better than a particular lacrosse player. Why would it make any kind of sense to artificially shrink their candidate pool?
This is also a moral thing, not just a political thing. It's not right to discriminate against people for reasons other than job performance.
> Lacrosse players tend to be white and male
I suspect they also tend to attend certain schools, and that could very well be causal.
> Why would it make any kind of sense to artificially shrink their candidate pool?
It doesn't make sense to shrink it if you have 10 candidates. But if you have thousands of resumes, it's not shrinking, it's filtering.
> It's not right to
It's naive to expect big corporations to act morally. Best you can do is force them to act legally.
That's not the only avenue. Big corporations do what their managers, customers, employees and investors want.
Eg restaurants will typically try to serve tasty food, even if there's no legal requirement to do so.
Similarly Google has free lunch, because that's what employees want.
The recent fad for ESG shows that investor can want 'morality', too, and companies are willing to satisfy them. (I quote 'morality', because different people have different ideas, and often people only want the fig-leaf of morality, but not pay the price for what they would consider real morality. See eg greenwashing.) Customers and investors etc get what they are willing to pay for, and that's not necessarily what they say they want.
But the explicit, stated goal of diversity efforts is specifically to exclude candidates who otherwise might do well, but are not diverse, because non-diverse teams can't perform as well as diverse teams.
Most diversity efforts are to get more diverse candidates or remove potential bias from interviews. This excludes no one.
Whilst, yes, everything else being equal some non-zero knowledge of reliable proxies is useful. But in a hiring process, not everything is equal. You can, eg., trivially examine the candidate.
its trivial to get actually relevant data to hiring, making "AI" dangerously useless. Is substitutes a high-quality process (measurements of the actual applicants) for a low-quality process (random statistical properties of aggregates of existing employees).
The story of "AI" over the last decade, it must be said.
If you are poor and want to give your child a name to signal success, you'd need to look at the names rich people are giving their kids right now. In practice at most we are seeing poor people imitating the past naming practices of rich people. (Of course, that's just a generalisation. Individual people make their individual choices.)
not go all critical race theory, but is this all that matters? should there not be a place in society for people who have lesser aptitude for corporate work?
Look for round holes before pounding a round peg into a square hole.
I am not going to assume that without further investigation. I am rather skeptical of the robustness of predictive models in the absence of relevant causal relationships.
See the correlation now?
Except that in golf's case, you usually see golf played around the country by rich white guys. Lacrosse is pretty much a northeastern thing, and when it's played elsewhere, it's normally at schools with the resources to host those clubs.