Anyway, this isn't an example of cancelation. You can't cancel a dead person. He wasn't killed by Twitter, he apparently died of illness.
What negative consequences, other than some people having a negative opinion of him?
There's nothing inherently wrong with people having a negative opinion of another person, that happens all the time. It's not a phenomenon to be worried about.
And I wasn't saying he was canceled, I meant that he was bullied for 'defending' someone who was being bullied.
Yes, but Robbie Coltrane wasn't socially outcast.
> I meant that he was bullied for 'defending' someone who was being bullied.
Replaced "bullied" with "criticized".
The President of the United States is routinely and vehemently criticized. Hated by millions of people. And yet, he is not socially outcast. Nor is he bullied. And his mental and physical health seem ok for someone his age, or in any event, he doesn't appear to be suffering from feeling socially outcast.
Being criticized is not the same thing as being canceled. It's not even close.
Degrees on the same scale
> Replaced "bullied" with "criticized".
Criticized publicly and unfairly, I'll stick with bullied.
> The President of the United States is routinely and vehemently criticized. Hated by millions of people. And yet, he is not socially outcast. Nor is he bullied.
I am sure he suffers from any amount of bullying and criticism he's receiving that he knows about.
> I am sure he suffers from any amount of bullying and criticism he's receiving that he knows about.
Doubtful, given he's probably insulated from that because as a politician 100% of his career he's always had roughly 50% of the people against him give or take.
Trump on the other hand couldn't take criticism because he wasn't a career politician, which would be a breath of fresh air honestly if it wasn't a rich narcissist at the wheel. Maybe a school teacher, or musician, hell even Tom Hanks. He got sucked into twitter wars, the current admin has a hotshot Twitter team that delivers blows but again keeps him insulated from it. That's the mark of a leader.
I say this as someone who did NOT vote for Joe because I refuse to vote for an establishment candidate for the Presidential ticket, though I was relieved he won, for the sake of democracy and so we don't devolve into fascism. I was also glad Trump won though, not because I wanted anything he was selling but felt maybe having the crappiest timeline might push the left to the progressives if we fully just give up supporting them. It kinda worked. Overton window has shifted maybe 0.2 % but any give is good.
I don't expect great things from Joe, not by a long shot. I long for the day that the presidential races are decided by ranked choice voting or similar systems. Then maybe we can get some good leaders from regular society who maybe could lead better than the rich bastards who run everything else.
I mean it worked well for Ukraine, sure President Zelenskyy wasn't always the best, and had issues earlier in his Presidency, and such but he was a freaking actor and comedian, now he's a war hero and rightly so. The west gave him a ticket out, to escape and he stayed with his people to fight. That's pretty bold. You know none of our leaders on either side would be brave enough for that.
Strange comment. Just because you haven't seen it in your feed doesn't mean it isn't happening.
https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/scottish-news/tr...
You can certainly cancel his memory, which, for the people closed to said dead person, might matter a lot.
People grumbling about the views of a dead person is pretty damned harmless, isn't it? JK Rowling is "canceled" but she's still getting book and movie deals. Like Dave Chapelle, "cancelled" is a highly profitable status.
The problem is people thinking they actually have a right or privilege to a platform, you don't and never did. Nobody had a 'platform' in the 80s, but now everybody thinks they're an internet celebrity if they have 1000+ followers. You're not, if you say something bad you should be rightfully held accountable for it.
Any rich celebrity or business person like Elon Musk, could get shunned by all of society but they'd still do pretty good because of the money, pretty sure they won't cry too hard on their private jets.
Once you've made it, yes.
One of the problems with cancel culture is once someone has been cancelled the socially accepted and then unchallenged view of who are what they becomes over time an increasingly extreme caricature. JKR is just an unapologetic second-wave feminist, and that in itself is a socially and philosophically reasonable position to take (even if you don’t happen to agree with it).
The really point isn't to find who is guilty, which is why these witch hunts almost more often than not targets people on the left that dare stick out their neck or ask the wrong questions, usually left-of-center moderate liberals.
I was trying to find a nice summary in written form of her theses, but here's a nice podcast discussion on Arendt's totalitarinism: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j_fV_2LOL6Y
It's a fairly nuanced and insightful discussion. She holds Stalinism as the most complete example of totalitarianism, in front of the Nazis, and especially the Italian fascists who she merely considers has totalitarian tendencies.
I didn't say it was. But whether the comparison is Hitler or Stalin, it's absurd, because both cases involved mass murder, and nothing even remotely comparable is happening with social media.
It's possible to say a ball is round like a melon, even if the ball does not share the color or pattern or size.
The similarity I'm noting is the erasure of the private life, the arbitrarily shifting rules of what is acceptable, the relentless witch hunts, the irrelevance of guilt and truth, the fear that you might be next.
Which is, to Arendt, some of the defining hallmarks of totalitarianism.
Except that tweets are nonviolent, whereas totalitarianism is extremely violent. If you wanted to make a subtler point, you started off on the wrong foot. Your original comment felt over the top to me.
I would argue with that. :-)
In general, the rhetoric over "cancel culture" feels very over the top to me. There's a level of fearmongering and victimhood that's not warranted by the empirical facts, much like whenever it's claimed that there's a "crime wave". I'm not saying there's no crime, or no cancellation, just that I don't see totalitarianism as a natural next step from Twitter.
The myth of Fascism (that she called totalitarism, but in this case it's the same, the roots are bonapartism) is "Our group is the best, and everybody should aim to be like us (Poles, French, Dalmatians, but also anarchists if we're talking about USSR... Depends on the flavor). But we aren't at the place we deserve because those other groups infiltrated us and we have traitors working agaisnt us (historically Jews, but also anybody "weakening" your group, like trans and handicaped people in Nazi germany, or pacifists in 1914). We need to get rid of the traitors and we will be as strong as we deserve."
Yes, the society is becoming more fascist (or totalitarist if you want to use Arendt terms), but there is one reason to not be down: they are stupider than they were in 1920s. "Neofascists" are basic protofascists at best, with no real ideals, barely adopted the "great replacement" theory which is at best a rehashing of a 1900 theory. They did not read Nietszche but the Bible, and now seems to base their ideals in religion, which in my opinion, made them weaker.
Something else?