Annie Ernaux’s Justly Deserved Nobel
newyorker.com
newyorker.com
A memoir implies some kind of mediation, transformation and interpretation. Writing life "directly as we experience it" is not a memoir but a journal.
Ernaux is a journalist who only ever reports on herself and who finds everything that happens to her, extraordinary. That includes shopping in supermarkets, having affairs, getting an abortion, riding the subway, and did I mention shopping.
It's extraordinary alright that she won the Nobel. But before that, not so much.
She thinks her life is fascinating, as she examines it in excruciating detail, but that doesn't make it interesting for anyone else. At least not for me.
Another curious feature is that she revisits the same meager events in several books. I'm guessing it's because she lacks new material, but her fans must feel at home when they read the same story over and over again.
TFA compares her to Simenon, which is outrageous; Simenon was one of the most inventive and creative novelist of his time (as well as prolific).
When Dylan won the Nobel many people were unhappy, because they thought he wasn't a writer proper. But there is infinitely more adventure and storytelling, and understanding of the human plight in any of his songs than in the books of Ernaux that I have read.
I'm listening now to "Motorpsycho Nightmare"... It's so good!
But judging from your comments here, I don’t fancy you a New Yorker reader.
I think strangely the best way to understand what Ernaux is doing (which you obviously haven’t if that wasn’t clear enough) is to read Leiris introduction to L’age d’homme. She is mostly aiming for the same goal he is. She actually used a quote from him at the beginning of L’Evenement and I guess she didn’t restate what Leiris did because well he has already done so.
It states that Simenon was a precursor to the nouveau roman, "of Robbe-Grillet’s faith in describing only the surface of events", and that Ernaux is a successor to this.
There are two problems with this theory.
One, the nouveau roman doesn't just describes the "surface of events", but every little object in minute detail. It wants to be neutral, to deliver a scene as free of prejudice as possible, so that the reader may form her own opinion. It can spend pages describing a door handle that no one in the room will ever touch.
This is not what Simenon is doing.
And second, this is not what Ernaux is doing either. Her style is flat and without flourishes, but she doesn't shy away from moral judgement and self-aggrandizement. In "L'Événement" (published in 2000), she compares her abortion to the experience of "solo navigators", of "going somewhere where others will never think of going".
At the time abortion was illegal and dangerous, but that didn't make it rare. By some estimates [0] there were over 800,000 abortions a year in France in the 1960s. So many, many women did in fact go there, risking their reputation, their freedom and their life; something her self-centeredness prevents her from seeing or even inquiring about.
[0] Anne-Marie Dourlen-Rollier, La vérité sur l'avortement, Paris 1963
Obviously he does. It’s an article about Simenon. Have you ever read one of his books? Reading Maigret is basically walking from a French cliché to another one.
> This is not what Simenon is doing.
Nor is Gopnik pretending he is. He is merely using the phrase “presaged aspects of the nouveau roman”.
Gopnik is being awfully nice to Simenon in his article. He is trying to elevate what is mostly a serial producer of crime novels even if a good one to a higher position. He does so somewhat convincingly actually.
He compares him to Ernaux not for an obsession for details but for their mutual ability to only describe the surface of events - basically what you are reproaching to Ernaux.
I don't know if it's in an interview or in the book itself that she compares her experience to the like of a solo navigator (so I may be wrong, I had never heard of her before today), but since she wrote this book in 2000, she was able to see the evolution of things, and compared to a time with google, planned parenthood, and families and friend becoming more and more accepting, it must have felt like going into the unknown. She didn't have a crew, nor internet, she might have felt alone, surounded by a sea of people she didn't think would understand.
> By some estimates [0] there were over 800,000 abortions a year in France
The reason it's an estimate is because they were illegals, no official records, must have been derived from court cases, deaths. Many abortions were/are made alone with a coat hanger or knitting needle, by mixing medicine and/or poisons. I don't know if it was Ernaux' case, but that's the kind of things many, even desperate, will never think of doing, and yet many others will, and each of them must have felt/will feel alone.