What’s wrong with that? Uber provides more value than cabs so people pay more.
Curb is a bit more expensive than a street hail but generally less than Uber due to a lack of surge pricing. When it's raining, Uber is about 2x the price of a cab. When it's busy after an event at Madison Square Garden, Uber is about 3x the price of a cab. On a recent Friday evening, Uber was showing $105 for a 25 minute ride with a relatively long wait. I hailed a cab and it was $28 for the same ride. Both prices exclude tip.
Note, of course, that this is my own personal experience in NYC over the last year and will not apply to all cities or even all locations in NYC.