Puerto Ricans call themselves subjects of colonialism yet continually reject both statehood and complete independence. It seems like Puerto Ricans want the worst of both worlds.
Puerto Ricans call themselves subjects of colonialism yet continually reject both statehood and complete independence. It seems like Puerto Ricans want the worst of both worlds.
It leads to some interesting incentives for folks there, especially in gov’t, if they know how to poke certain populist buttons.
The voting demographics also favor one party over the other, if one cares to look, and if admitted as a state may cause swings and imbalances in the current two-party detente. This is similar to Washington D.C.
The current balance has a lot of defacto non-obvious benefits for politicians that their constituents might not appreciate if they fully knew about them.
Most US households in general haven't paid federal income tax in the past couple of years. In a good year it's close to 50-50.
There is a whole ecosystem of companies in the island for instance which use this for tax arbitrage, providing services for mainland folks at lower rates because of it, which they couldn’t do if they had the same tax rates.
The economy there is… unusual, partially because of it’s current semi-favored situation. If it had to play in an even playing field from the mainland US, it isn’t clear what it would look like, but it would probably shift to even more of a resort/retirement place (like Hawaii), which is not to the locals benefit in many cases.
At least if they want jobs that aren’t just hospitality type jobs, which aren’t for everyone.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_Puerto_Rican_status_refer...
US government's rejecting Puerto Rico's statehood
I suspect Manchin and pals want to make sure we continue to be ruled by a minority of the voters.
That said, most of my awareness is Wikipedia and second-hand account, but I heard most of the abstainers weren't protesting "against statehood" but against the meaningless nature of the vote itself because it was non-binding to anyone, its results weren't going to be used to do anything (and indeed did not ultimately matter other than a couple of wishy-washy President Obama words but no actions).
I'm probably wrong on that interpretation, too, but the two votes after the 2012 vote seem to align with that: there is a desire for statehood over alternatives, but that there also seems to a feeling of neglect that they can vote all they want and Congress itself has yet to certify the votes or to make the necessary movements towards an actual, binding vote.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puerto_Rico_political_status_p...