An open door to anyone who wants to make records for the sake of fun and glory.
Closed door if your stated purpose is to belittle people or make controversy.
https://www.iphronline.org/turkmenistan-continued-repression...
Human rights track record bad? No problem! We're all having fun right?
Participate in TV show that mocks things? Ooh, no, we're the gate keeper of moral choices now.
I will work with a bad person to do a good thing. I will not work with a good person to do a bad thing. My participation is based on the morality of the thing that I am doing, not the other person's past or context .
To put it technically, the focus is on the first order action and effect.
This is in contrast to an increasingly popular moral assessment based on speculative second and third order effects.
However opening up trade with North Korea, Iran, Russia etc doesn’t seem a good way of handling the situation.
I would have no problem if the US collaborated on building hospitals with Russia at the same time we are also in conflict with them elsewhere. Support the good that you want to see in the world and others. Don't support the bad
But this is an attempt to obscure human rights atrocities, or at least using the money they gain from them to say "we hold a world record!".
There are accusations of forced participations in public spectacles in there, regardless of environmental conditions (ie: heat). If they'll do that for his birthday, would they do that for a world record attempt?
How much of a "good thing" is a world record attempt if the participants are compelled by the state and end up putting themselves at risk?
Further, the stated rationale from Guinness is "we are a family oriented brand". I can understand them not having done much research about a dictator initially, and maybe being unaware.
Only they haven't actually done anything consistent with that when it has been highlighted this individual is using their records as part of a propaganda machine in a very oppressive state. They in fact defended "their record holders".
Family oriented? Or profit oriented?
Your point that record setting can be secondarily used as a propaganda tool feeds directly into my point above about considerations of primary action versus secondary and tertiary actions.
By that logic we shouldn't help a dictator build a school or a hospital, because it could be used for propaganda.
This is what I reject
- Regime has a track record of human rights abuses - Company takes payment, sends out judge, stamps out record - Company takes a stance as "family values oriented" - Company is then subjected to press coverage pointing out they are working with human rights abuser. - The only public statement they have made is in support of their "record holders". Nothing revoked, revisited, reviewed.
If they had "family values", why wouldn't they do this upon learning about who they work with?
It's been a number of years, and they have done nothing.
This is not the consistent position worthy of respect you think it is.
You additionally keep going back to devil's advocate about choices you could make as an individual. You seem to decline to look further into what is happening between a regime lead by an individual and a for profit company, beyond holding them up as... admirable.
If you did, you would now know the individual in question does things like take political prisoners, expose the population to harm (mass participation record attempts during a pandemic), spend billions on world record attempt buildings, and more.
It's clear cut. The company involved is not achieving any tangible real world good. They are protecting someone who paid them. Building the world's biggest X is not providing any social value.
To pretend that a giant statue record is the same as a school or hospital is disingenuous.
I basically laid it all out in my first post.
Some people don't see it as wrong to work with bad people if you don't directly hurt anyone.
You obviously disagree.
More evidence that someone is bad doesn't change this.