Privacy and freedom should be the legacy we leave
fsf.org
fsf.org
”bigoted parents”? Who are you refering to, FSF?
It’s the parents’ right to raise their children to adhere to any religious beliefs or ideologies, even those you do not agree with! Regardless, it’s not your job to dictate how parents should raise their children.
Although a relationship of trust and respect of privacy should be established between a parent and their child, this should not be taken to an extreme. The internet can be quite wild, it’s neglectful to let your child consume whatever content they come across and speak to whomever they like. It’s a parent’s job to set healthy limits to these things. This does involve keeping a healthy culture of openness in the home, which contradicts the notion of privacy (from their “bigoted parents”) that you’re advocating children should have.
I am a privacy advocate myself, and am against mass-surveillance by the state. Here is the problem though: pedophiles and groomers do exist. The way we mitigate this problem is not by giving the tyrants more power, it’s by empowering parents by providing them with the tools to limit exposure to these threats. This gives power to the (bigoted lol) parents to filter out the bad and keep as much good as possible.
The companies that are bribing tyrants to partake in the surveillance system should have their leadership thrown in prison. The companies that provide solutions for us to protect our children should be rewarded and praised.
tl;dr it's not a "lifestyle" and you're not "socialized" into it. The fact you believe otherwise is a very discomfiting recontextualization of your other remarks in this thread about "protecting children from groomers" and "filtering out the bad". People like you are precisely why children need the ability to communicate privately with non-parental figures - thank you for proving the FSF's point.
I am a bi man.
I can promise you that hearing "gay people should be stoned to death" from the elders of my parent's church did not socialize me into my "lifestyle" (this is a misnomer, as I'm not even actively dating a man right now...)
The only thing that made my teenage years bearable was what little privacy I could create for myself. Thankfully, the Internet was young and I was able to find supportive communities that helped me navigate these challenges. Without that, the only messaging from every authority or leadership figure in my life was that I was an abomination, going to hell, and unworthy of love.
I don't know how I would have survived without that outlet in an otherwise restrictive/repressive environment.
Homophobes, I should imagine. For a start.
>Here is the problem though: pedophiles and groomers do exist
Abusive parents also exist. Rather more commonly than pedophiles too, I'll wager.
> This gives power to the (bigoted lol) parents to filter out the bad and keep as much good as possible
Can you not see the ways this might go horribly wrong? Have you never bumped into a brain-dead internet filter?
Saying that “parents can be abusive” isn’t an argument against giving parents in general authority over their children. Generally, parents are the most trustworthy individuals in a child’s life.
Besides, if you widen the definition of abuse enough then you can turn 50% of parents abusive. Lots of deception has been done around the word “abuse” by silently widening the definition and then labeling people abusive to make it seem like they’re something they’re not.
Citation needed.
It's an argument against giving parents total authority. Have you heard the saying "it takes a village to raise a child"? This modern phenomenon of parents maintaining an iron grip over where children go, who they interact with, and what ideas they're exposed to is a historical aberration, and it's not healthy. Even now, as it is, we still spread that responsibility out - people who homeschool their children are viewed with some suspicion, the moreso if they keep them socially isolated while doing so, for it is frequently a sign of cult grooming.
Children need protection and nurturing, yes, but they're still people who exist in society - not property.
That parents are generally the most trustworthy individuals in a child's life should be common sense. I may not agree with every parent’s ideology or beliefs, but I will stand for their right to have a parental role in their own children’s lives. You seem to believe that this right should be revoked if their ideas on homosexuality don’t align with yours.
>who they interact with
Parents have a responsibility to make sure that their child is not interacting with people who might hurt them, or be a negative influence on them.
>and what ideas they're exposed to
Citation needed. I’m sure religious parents teach their children about homosexuality, they just mention it’s a sin rather than saying that it’s a person’s valid choice. They teach the moral standards that they believe are the truth and will benefit their child.
You want to impose your standards of morality instead, which I’m saying is certainly not within your or the FSF’s right.
>people who homeschool their children are viewed with some suspicion
Really? I’ve never heard this opinion before. Homeschooling is perfectly fine, and parents that I’ve heard do it let their children interact with other children who’re homeschooled as well. They are thought together, at least sometimes.
>they're still people who exist in society - not property
Don’t lie. Don’t straw-man what I said. Parents have many rights over their children, but that does not mean that anybody here is likening them to a watch or a pair of slippers. These sorts of dishonest responses are getting tiresome.
As has been pointed out to you multiple times, it's neither of those - it's an innate property.
Let's drag this into the open and make it concrete.
I do consider telling someone a child that their innate properties are sinful and will condemn them to eternal fire to be abusive, yes. I will proudly impose that standard of morality on others to the extent of my ability. I believe homosexuality is not wrong, and that parents who believe that it is wrong often inflict great psychological trauma on their own children, trauma which can be partially mitigated through support networks they sustain outside of parental control, often over the internet. There is a commenter right here in this thread who corroborates this with their personal experience growing up.
Now, what are your views? We already know some of them - that being gay is a "lifestyle" one is "socialized" into, and that it's a question of "moral standards". So out with it - do you think homosexuality is wrong? Are you prepared to defend that stance in a public forum?
They are referring to my parents, and other parents like them.
Parents who are so disgusted by the idea of homosexuality that they will disown their kids or send them to "re-education" camps or retreats.
Parents who force their kids to attend churches where leadership will actively talk about the sinfulness of being gay, and how such a thing is deserving of death by stoning and an eternity in hell.
Parents who are more interested in enforcing puritanical beliefs during the most formative years of a kid's life than they are in ensuring their kids develop a healthy sense of self and psychological safety.
This is not hyperbole, this was my childhood. My ability to find support outside of my family and church circle without intervention from my parents is arguably why I am alive today.
Interesting, some religions think it's sinful to eat pork or seafood or beef, and actively forbid it. Others think it's sinful to have premarital sex or to gamble or even to drink. I wonder how you feel about them. Should every child's upbringing adhere to your moral worldview? Or maybe mine? Or maybe the politician-du-jour?
I hope this reductio ad absurdem is a reminder that one shouldn't be too shy of imposing one's moral sensibilities on others - that is what they are for. My moral standard is that you shouldn't inflict unnecessary pain and suffering on people, bleeding heart liberal that I am. As such I am happy to condemn gay conversion therapy (along with genital mutilation and incestuous rape) as Bad (and forbidding eating beef as No Big Deal).
This really isn't a live-and-let-live situation, it's a child abuse situation.
My parents believed literally every one of these things, and more. They believed not just that sex is sinful, but any form of physical touch, kissing, etc is sinful.
But compared to the subject of sexual orientation, those things were just annoyances in the bigger scheme of things (this is not to imply they were not harmful).
But when religious beliefs are literally about one's innate/unchangeable traits/identity, that leaves even deeper scars.
It left me with C-PTSD and I've spent my entire adult life trying to build a foundation for myself that my parents never did. It's grueling work and has required years of therapy, but I'm managing.
> Should every child's upbringing adhere to your moral worldview?
No, of course not.
But let's try something else on for size. A non-religious parent yells/screams/beats their kids. They neglect their kid's education, and they create an environment in which the child is unsure what is safe, what is real, what is true. They prevent their kid from learning about core subjects in school that might threaten the parent's power over them, and isolate them from other families who might give them a hint that a life without beatings is even possible.
We call parents like these abusers. The kids of these parents are emotionally scarred, and have an uphill battle ahead of them in life.
Yet somehow, when the parent does all of these things in the name of religion, some people stop believing it's abuse, and it's just their "worldview".
Abuse is abuse. Shitty parenting is shitty parenting. Religion doesn't change that.