I don't see how the points you stated are contradictory. Suppose you have a side gig that makes up 3% of your yearly income (eg. if you make $200k/yr, that works out to $6k/yr), and the HOA wants to shut you down. Sure, it's not your main job and is a trivial portion of your overall revenue and shutting it down is certainly an option, but you'd be pretty pissed that you're getting shut down and you'll probably show up to the next HOA meeting to stop that ban from getting passed.