Not dead, just resting: How discredited technologies can be unexpectedly resurrected
economist.com
economist.com
You can discredit any technology -- or overestimate it, for that matter -- by analyzing it on a short enough time scale, just as you can take a random walk and interpret it as a series of dramatic surges and crashes.
The first time I tried out Dvorak, I had to hack around in ResEdit, make a new keyboard layout, and then glue labels to a keyboard cover. If I weren't 12 years old, I would never have had time to bother. And even then, I gave up after a few days because I had homework due that I needed to type up fast, and couldn't afford to put up with hunt-and-peck.
When I tried again in college, everything was all preinstalled, and I just had to change a Keyboard setting. And I could alt-shift to go back to Qwerty, so if something urgent came in - say, I had to respond to an instant message - I could do that and then go back to learning.
Later Facebook may have succeeded in not making it a joke.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=328767
I think it's an interesting idea though. How many things sort of fade, or don't take off, only to be resurrected and achieve popularity elsewhere?
What do other folks think about duplicates?
I don't really care - unless pg creates some kind of market for the karma points I have accumulated, they're worthless (like ideas?:-)
So, I don't think any kind of market using current karma as the currency would work at all. Karma will only start becoming dangerous (in raganwald's sense) when it's transactional and capped, and thus scarce, and thus competitive with national currencies as a wealth proxy.