(Full disclosure: I have a science PhD)
By the end of it, I hated my supervisor so much I could barely manage to speak to him and I went out of my way to avoid him.
At the very end, after I'd done my viva and some minor corrections to my thesis I knew I've ticked all the boxes and the only thing left was to go in to clear out my lab space. At that point I simply didn't want to talk to anyone from the group so I went in very late one evening when I knew no-one would be around and packed up all my stuff and took it away.
I didn't say goodbye and there was no leaving party. I was there for three-and-a-bit years, and then I wasn't. I have had no contact with the group, or my supervisor, since.
I can easily imagine that someone with credentials / qualifications in a space might have issues with the system/community that appears to govern that space.
So did you read the paper and come up with a substantive scientific critique, or did you judge him on his social media activities and social opinions?
You seem to be criticizing the author of the paper instead of the paper itself, which, in my book, is itself a red flag.
Some areas of academia seem to do that to people. Nature even has a paper on it: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-00663-2