Deepfakes of Celebrities Have Begun Appearing in Ads, with or Without Permission
wsj.com
wsj.com
Sure, one of the hallmarks of great satire is that it requires robust disclaimers establishing it as satire.
Personally, I see no reason not to have a blanket ban on unauthorized deep fakes of living people in marketing, especially if having an actor pretending to be another celebrity endorsing your product has been established as out of bounds. For what reason would it be used if not to confuse consumers?
Maybe we should stop giving individuals such power that someone impersonating them could result in a war.
Additionally impersonating someone for defomation or stealing money is already illegal.
Deepfakes map a different face onto a placeholder body, but often the placeholder body and the movements of the body are not really convincing to me. It looks more like a celebrity mask on a different person. Very uncanny valley to me.
I'm not suggesting that deepfakes won't keep improving or aren't a real problem. And maybe this is just about my own (lack of?) ability to recognize faces. But it is something I think about often when I read these stories and I wonder if it is just me.
For example, the header image in the story of "Elon Musk" tied up doesn't look anything like Elon to me. It looks like a random neighbor/co-worker who maybe has a resemblance to him. The age/weight/hair just aren't that close to the real thing.
Now imagine you are walking through Times Square. There’s 1000 pictures. 2 of them are fake. Do you know which ones? Even if it doesn’t happen to you personally, a certain % of ppl will just subconsciously accept “oh yeah [Johnny deep] ad with [Nike]” and then move on.
In other words, your guard is not up 24/7
Obviously this is muddied with fair use and political (someone seeking public office) ads which allow for some liberties.
It's my opinion the technology should be completely banned in the political sphere, with felony-level penalties attached for violating.
Today, that controversy would not even be perceived the lies are so blatant and curiously uncontroversial.
If we go back though, politicians lied in other ways. They made promises the knew they could not keep and of course they'd blame the opposition for torpedoing their policies --but in most cases they knew full well that it was nothing more than fanciful thinking and it would not come to be.