By that exact same reasoning, couldn't literally anyone else do this? If we start blurring the definition, why does it conveniently stop there?
By that exact same reasoning, couldn't literally anyone else do this? If we start blurring the definition, why does it conveniently stop there?
Sure.
I don't think anyone is getting dinged or getting special affirmative action consideration for listing themselves as unspecified multi-racial.
If someone checks a box that gets them special affirmative action consideration, and it makes up no part of their application, and it doesn't pass the sniff test at the alumni interview, then a note will probably be made that race, appearances, and application do not appear consistent, and they will proceed from there.
The admissions officers are looking for a compelling narrative to admit the applicant. It's up to the applicant to provide that compelling narrative.
If I were advising someone who is multi-racial with an affirmative action twist while not really looking the part, I would recommend that they make a note of it in their application. Note that being part Black while appearing very White usually has some impact on shaping the person's identity.
For reference, I knew one person at an elite school who would introduce herself in icebreakers as "My name is $NAME, and I am Black"... and her skin was extremely pale white. She had a Black grandfather who had a scandalous affair with a White woman (when and where that was not apparently acceptable) to produce one of her parents. She told us stories about how that impacted her identity. I imagine she may have written a little bit about it in her one or more of her admissions essays.