Frankly, your comparison doesn't make much sense. The administration is making an obvious effort, but there's a big difference between investing in startups and attempting to patch an economy that looks like it will collapse. Investing in startups is quite literally an investment for a future economy. The bailout was a bit of the opposite -- a quick-and-dirty patch up.
If startups were important they could have just cancelled the V-22 Osprey program which eats $2.8 billion per year, or ballistic missile defense at $9.9 billion, or DHS at $60 billion.
$1 billion dollars over three years is probably less money than the gov't spends on toilet cleaning. It's equivalent to withdrawing from Iraq a week early. Sorry, if I'm unimpressed it doesn't look like effort, it looks like a PR campaign.
Think of it this way:
Why would the government invest in Facebook or Twitter when there are plenty of people who already have their wallets open? That goes for many tech startups -- YCombinator alone is very beneficial for the government in an indirect way because the government no longer needs to think about funding tech startups -- someone else is already doing it really well for them.
So the real necessity for government intervention is for extremely risky and potentially extremely unprofitable ventures that allow for amazing possibilities (think NASA when the US was afraid of the Soviets). Pure scientific research is often this way as well.
And even NASA is a small fraction of the federal budget (I remember Neil DeGrasse Tyson repeating "half a penny to a dollar" a lot.
So my point is this: startups, research, or pretty much any economy-advancing investments aren't going to exceed the cost of trying to keep people happy. The War in Iraq is an example: we wouldn't be there if we weren't scared 10 years ago. We wouldn't have been eager to go to war unless it made us feel happier or safer or more content. In contrast, how content do people feel when they hear about a space shuttle explosion? Or money "wasted" on research that could be used to feed the poor?
Why did we even fund NASA again? Oh yeah, we were afraid. The United States collectively didn't give a crap about space until we imagined the Soviets creating the Death Star before us.
I'm not saying any of this is rational. Actually, I really agree with you, but the fact that money is going to startups is a good sign. The quantity is low because nothing will cost more than making people feel happy, safe, and secure right now.
I think you're both right and wrong that it's a PR campaign. It can be both. Something positive, and something done for political benefit. The context is that it's very hard to get a bill passed in Congress right now unless both parties support it, and the Republicans have repeatedly blocked efforts to do things that help middle/working class folks, or help the the most serious environmental problems, etc. unless there's also kickback to the richest Americans and their favored industries (oil, military, etc.), or at least doesn't have anything that drops tax cuts or closes loopholes for them. They've opposed extended unemployment checks, for example. They've brought the nation to the very brink of default on it's debts, on an issue which historically is a routine ceremony of raising the "ceiling". That brinkmanship alone scares people, raises fiscal and market uncertainty and has a negative effect on spending -- this is beyond obvious to economists, a no-brainer. They opposed extending payroll tax cuts which disproportionately help middle/lower income class folks, and that most economists will tell you have a positive economic stimulus effect. Trying to pass anything in Congress gets turned into a political point scoring match, regardless of the actual objective merit or wisdom of it's benefits. In that context, it's much easier for a President to figure out which things they can do, just within the power of the Executive branch, to do something positive, however far from ideal it might be.
"The bailout was a mess"
The efforts of big gumment to get people who couldn't afford a house into one that blew a housing bubble that popped and created the worst financial and economic disaster since the Great Depression "was a mess".
The 'bailout', that is, the TARP program was not "a mess" at all but a grand success:
(1) TARP made money. All or nearly all the money has been paid back with very high interest, about 11% per year.
As far as I know, all the TARP money will be paid back without difficulty.
(2) The money was nothing like a 'bailout' but just loans to tell the world that the institutions would not go bust. So, TARP stopped 'runs' on the banks.
(3) TARP was not a 'bailout' but just to solve a short-term 'liquidity' problem, that is, as in 'runs' on the banks.
Note: A 'liquidity' problem is when you are worth $10 million but have only $500 in cash and suddenly have a traffic ticket for $600 and have to pay up or go to jail right NOW.
You have the money but just don't have it in cash right away; you can get the cash easily enough but will need some days or weeks to do so.
So to solve your 'liquidity' problem, you get a loan using some of your $10 million in assets as collateral. The loan is not really at risk; you pay your $600 bill; then a few weeks later you repay your loan with interest.
You are not broke. You are not begging for welfare. The loan is not a gift. The loan is not at risk. The loan is NOT a 'bailout'.
(4) Secretary Paulson called the nine bank CEOs to DC, sat them on one side of a table with a form in front of them, and told them all, "You WILL sign this form before you leave here today.". They all signed.
Goldman Sachs was one of the nine, didn't want or need the money, signed, took the money, but paid it back, with interest, as soon as Paulson would permit.
(5) Paulson's main point was just to tell the world that those nine banks were NOT bust and, thus, to stop 'runs' on those banks.
What Paulson did was fine. It was a good solution to a serious problem. The effort cost the taxpayers $0.00 and actually showed a nice little profit (11% was HIGH interest for such a loan).
To have not done TARP, we might have had cascading runs on all the major financial institutions in the US and all of the industrialized world and, then, been well into a second Great Depression, WWIII, global nuclear war, etc.
Yet too many people want to leap to call TARP a 'bailout'. It was no such thing.
Lesson: Those sources that call TARP a 'bailout' you should realize are providing toxic sewage in place of information for a well informed citizenry. For such sources, you should put on a rubber suit, hold your nose, dump the swill, pull the chain, and call a toxic dump cleanup crew.
Why do these 'news' sources scream 'bailout'? Because they want to grab you by the heart and the gut so that your eyeballs will follow for their ads and know that to grab you they should scream versions of greed, corruption, danger, scandal, etc.
So, they spout glowing, fuming, bubbling, sticky, toxic nonsense.
If the newsies had actually informed us, then we wouldn't have gotten into the popped housing bubble nonsense in the first place. In Iraq, we would have known that there was no good evidence that Saddam had WMDs. If we invaded Iraq anyway, then we would have dumped the Saddam regime and gotten out in three weeks instead of staying for 10 years and losing 5000 dead, 50,000 wounded, and $1.5 trillion. If we had good information on Akrapistan, then we would have been out'a there years ago. With good information, China wouldn't have wiped out much of our textile, manufacturing, and other industries and been ripping off our intellectual property.
Meanwhile, back in the US, the media was telling us ALL about Brit, Paris, Lindsay, Kim, etc. BUMMER.
Bad information from the newsies, such as screaming 'bailout', is the worst and most dangerous problem facing civilization at present.
PG and HN don't like for me to criticize 'big media', but I do so anyway because the media nonsense is the most dangerous problem facing civilization at present. Sorry PG.
Note: A 'liquidity' problem is when you are worth $10 million but have only $500 in cash and suddenly have a traffic ticket for $600 and have to pay up or go to jail right NOW.
You have the money but just don't have it in cash right away; you can get the cash easily enough but will need some days or weeks to do so.
So to solve your 'liquidity' problem, you get a loan using some of your $10 million in assets as collateral. The loan is not really at risk; you pay your $600 bill; then a few weeks later you repay your loan with interest.
You are not broke. You are not begging for welfare. The loan is not a gift. The loan is not at risk. The loan is NOT a 'bailout'.
-------------------------------------------------
What would define a 'bailout' as then?
Your example may be a bit extreme. If you're "worth" $10 million, but don't have $500 in liquid cash, you're stupid. You're not prepared for every day eventualities in your line of work (or just life in general). When people are unprepared for otherwise predictable things (washing machine breaks, you need an oil change, flat tire, etc) they have to suck it up and deal with it. They don't get to tie up all their money in investments and have someone loan them money for 100% foreseeable day to day life realities.
"You have the money but just don't have it in cash right away; you can get the cash easily enough but will need some days or weeks to do so."
I get emails from these guys in Nigeria all the time.
"You are not broke. You are not begging for welfare. The loan is not a gift. The loan is not at risk. The loan is NOT a 'bailout'."
Yes, you are broke. No, you're not begging for welfare. But, the loan is a gift to save you from otherwise going to jail.
When normal people in their every day lives don't have a safety net/cushion/rainy-day-fund to fall back on, they're labelled irresponsible, lazy, deadbeats, or charged with "living beyond their means". But if a bank does it... WTF? It's just normal business?
It's to "help" someone in a "predicament". The context is that the someone is in trouble and to need the help is pejorative.
But with this definition, TARP was not a 'bailout'.
Help? The "help" is usually much like a gift and not likely to be paid back. The banks had to pay HIGH interest, and did. The US Treasury made out like vulture capital. In the end it was the banks, and their stockholders, who gave 'help' to the US Treasury and the US taxpayers.
Need? At least Goldman Sachs didn't need the money in any sense.
In most respects, the banks didn't really need the money; that's why they were able to pay back the money quickly with interest.
Any need there was was due just to the liquidity issue.
The main reason Paulson acted was to stop international runs on banks and, thus, save the world from something that stood to be worse than the financial collapse that caused the Great Depression.
Pejorative? Whatever the banks did wrong in blowing the housing bubble, the TARP effort was short term and not really the fault of the banks but caused by the Bear Stearns and Lehman problems and, thus, the FEAR (the seed of a bank run -- remember FDR) in the world that might have led to a run.
Recall also the 1987 stock market crash: Greenspan was at a big meeting, left, went to a phone, got the news, called the major NYC banks and told them "The window at the Fed is open". Greenspan was going to provide liquidity and avoid a liquidity problem that could have done serious damage.
My little example on the meaning of a liquidity problem was pitched at the grade school level. You SHOULD be able to understand it. Your reactions are way, WAY off base. If you don't like the ratio of $600 and $10 million, then assume $1 million and $10 million.
Or improve the example to be a college student who just inherited an office building worth $10 million but needs $600 for a DUI case. He's not broke, but he does have a liquidity problem. He can get the $600 but not in just a few minutes to get out of jail.
In finance, 'liquidity' is a crucial topic; you should quit straining to misunderstand it.
If you want a real example, then when my wife died, I faced $6000 in funeral expenses. I didn't have the $6000 in my checking account. But within the next month, I sold some stock, raised the $6000, and paid the bill. So I had a 'liquidity' problem. I could have borrowed money using the stock as collateral. Such a loan would not have been a 'bailout', or 'help' and nothing pejorative.
So yes, they were able to pay back TARP pretty easily.
[1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-28/secret-fed-loans-un...
When Greenspan did such money printing, he called it "rebuilding the balance sheets".
A 'secret' is that the large banks are creatures of the Fed. They just are.
Yes, it might be more fair to the taxpayers, who really gave the money to the banks, and who are BACKING the banks, to have the banks be so tightly regulated that they are "boring" with little chance of going bust or of putting people in the "1%". So, for the risky stuff, let hedge funds like MF Global, LTCM, etc. do that. And break up the big banks so that if one fails it won't bring down the whole economy. But these changes are too hot politically.
I doubt that the Fed's quantitative easing was the main reason those nine banks were able to pay back TARP. Again, TARP was just some fast money to stop runs on the banks and, as your data suggests, a relatively small amount of money.
So, why did the Fed print money and give it to the banks? Because otherwise we would have no financial system and, then, no economy and then hunger, revolution, war, massive death, etc., little things like that.
So, what happened to the money the banks were supposed to have, that is, the money the Fed replaced? It disappeared! Uh, actually with 'fractional reserve banking' the banks can essentially 'create money'. Or you borrow $100 from a bank and deposit the loan in your checking account. Then the bank loans out $90 which is deposited in a checking account. Then they loan out $81 which is deposited in a checking account. It's called the 'multiplier effect'. So, that's mostly the same $100 loaned out 3+ times.
It may be that the bank only has about $10 of the stockholders' money and the rest is from depositors via checking accounts ('demand deposits'). So, the bank has maybe $10 but about $300 loaned out.
Loaning money this way on 'financial assets', e.g., to buy stocks, especially on thin margin, that is, with high leverage, can blow an asset bubble -- 1929. So we passed some laws keeping banks from loaning money for such purposes and put in place some higher margin requirements. Then the sneaky bankers discovered houses, Fannie, Freddie, the CRA, adjustable rate mortgages, the Countrywide business model, and 'social justice' and blew a bubble based on housing instead of stocks.
When the stock market bubble burst in 1929, we got The Great Depression. When the housing bubble burst in 2008, we got The Great Recession. See a pattern here?
Now if the economy gets sick from, say, a popped bubble, then some of that $300 in loans won't get paid back. If as much as $10 of that $300 doesn't come back, then the bank is bust. In simple terms, that's what happened in the housing bubble, both its growth and its shrinkage.
So, when the bubble burst, some of that $300 or so the bank created is destroyed.
So, we can try to continue on with that money destroyed, but that would cause deflation. In a credit economy, deflation is a bummer because the easy way to make money is just not to spend it and just to put it under a mattress. So the economy goes into the tank and just stays there as people get poor, sick, cold, and dead. We can get wars that way. At least we can get people 'occupying' city parks.
So, the Fed is trying to avoid deflation. But the economy is very sick, and even with interest rates near 0.00% per year the economy is plenty sick. Why? We don't get good answers from the newsies, not even Bloomberg, but first cut businesses don't want to borrow for inventory, expansion, etc. because the customers aren't coming, and the banks don't want to lend because the businesses are sick and might not pay back. Or, the Fed's money has the banks flush again, but that money is not yet in the hands of small businesses and consumers.
Maybe a better solution would have been Milton Friedman's Helicopter: Print up some money, about what was destroyed, load it into a helicopter, fly across the US, scatter it, and let people pick it up and spend it. This is not entirely a joke.
There is a great title for a magazine and maybe a Web site -- Secret Romantic Confessions. It's TOO tempting not to look! Well, Bloomberg is a newsie site so has Fed "secrets", 'secret money given away'. BS. Total, 100%, reeking, fuming, bubbling, sticky BS. Grab'm by the heart, gut, and below the belt nonsense BS and collect the ad revenue. Net, Bloomberg is spouting nonsense to get yahoos up on their hind legs. Deliberate, deceptive, destructive nonsense. Of COURSE the Fed gave money to the banks: That's EXACTLY what 'quantitative easing' meant to anyone but a total yahoo, idiot, fool. There was no 'secret' involved!
It was just such nonsense from yahoos that was largely responsible for killing about 100 million people from the crash in 1929 to the end of WWII in 1945. How? Because when the US stock market bubble burst in 1929, a LOT of money the banks had created by loaning money to buy stocks on thin margin was destroyed. Remember "The Roaring 20's?" -- lots of parties from lots of money created by bank lending.
So, when the bubble burst, we had no banking system. Even out in Kansas, depositors lost 100%. We were back to a barter economy. We had massive deflation:
"For Sale. Nearly new car. Lost all in stock market. No offer too low."
"Deflation is the easiest thing in the world to fix: Just print money.". But we didn't. Various yahoos didn't understand we needed to PRINT MONEY. However even Betty Boop understood. Still we didn't.
So we went from 1929 to 1941 refusing to print money as needed. Unemployment was a disaster. Some of the problems in loss of US 'social capital' are STILL with us. Dumb. Really dumb.
Since the US was not buying, foreign developed economies were not selling to us. Since part of their economy was not selling, that part was not buying, and other sellers in that economy were not selling. Nearly no one was either buying or selling. The economy shut down. People were cold and hungry. So, the sickness of the US economy spread around the developed world.
Then along comes a wacko house painter with a solution: "Ein Folk. Ein Reich. Ein Führer". He gets dictatorial powers over the economy for four years. With those powers, actually he puts people back to work, building roads, bridges, ships, guns, tanks, etc. Yes, he abolishes the labor unions. Then he gets four more years of dictatorial powers and decides that he wants some new 'living space', say, to the east to a line from, say, Stalingrad to Moscow to Leningrad or, really, just to the Urals. For the people there, kill a lot of them right away (as 'inferior breeds') and kill the rest slowly as slaves on 1000 calories a day. What he did resulted in 50 million, maybe 100 million, people dead.
Then in 1941 or so people started shooting at us.
Then we got serious, and in about three months we had about three jobs for everyone who could work and were OUT of the Great Depression. Why? We printed enough money to start to replace what was destroyed in the 1929 market crash.
For now? We can be back to work anytime we want within about three months -- JUST PRINT MONEY. That's what the Fed is trying to do, but apparently Friedman's Helicopter would be more effective.
There's more, but I know; I know: This is post is already too long for a trivial little subject like putting 25 million people back to work. But, gotta tell you: Don't look for anything real on this subject from the newsies.
But, if another 100 million people die, or a billion or few, then the newsies will be right there reporting on the pains, the passion, pathos, and poignancy, with poetry, about the human suffering. They won't have even as much as a weak little hollow hint of a tiny clue about what caused the problem or how to fix it, but they can report what it 'feels' like.
It's infuriating because people don't understand when the gov't actually acts in their best interest - even if it doesn't seem like that.
As you so rightly pointed out, without TARP and the actions of the Fed, we would probably be in WW3 right now. People just don't get that.
Btw, this is partisan politics aside - because both Geithner and Paulson did a fabulous job at handling the worst crisis their generations have ever seen.
There was GM!
Some of the money the US Treasury 'invested' in GM may not get paid back.
So, we might say that GM got 'bailed out'.
Hmm. As I understand it, there was a little more to the story:
One approach to GM was just to let it go through an ordinary bankruptcy. But DC didn't want that.
Why? My understanding is that in an ordinary bankruptcy, GM would have gotten off the hook in their labor contracts to pay for retirees' health and pensions but, then, by law, the US Federal Government, that is, taxpayers, would have to make up the difference.
So, if all these guesses at the facts are correct, then, net, the 'arranged' bankruptcy essentially wiped out the stockholders, cost the Treasury some money, gave much of GM to the UAW pension and health care funds, and got the US Treasury off the hook for propping up ('bailing out') the UAW pension and health funds, then maybe, net, the Treasury came out best possible!
So, when there is screaming about the 'bailout' of GM, remember that the final arrangement was likely the "lesser of two weevils".
For the GM stockholders, well, GM messed up big time. So, first cut, in simple terms, it was up to the owners, that is, the stockholders to take the loss.
For a real 'bailout', there is Solyndra, ESPECIALLY after the renegotiation that had the taxpayers go from being first in line to get paid to being last in line to get paid.
And AIG was a real 'bailout'. The idea of bailing out AIG was to stop the spread of the sickness just at AIG. In part AIG was a bailout because it was not at all clear that AIG could repay. Last I heard, AIG may actually, finally, by slowly selling off everything it had, including its pens and pencils in Hong Kong, be able to pay back all the Federal bailout money. It was still a bailout.
But TARP, no, that was a vulture capital loan from the lender of last resort, the US Treasury, not 'help', not a 'gift', not really at risk, and not really a 'bailout'.
Of course, in all of this, the real villain is DC and what it did, especially having Fannie and Freddie back junk paper, in blowing the housing bubble. Why was the bubble so bad? Because during the price rising, there was a lot of dirty mortgage manipulations going on. But mostly the problem was that when the bubble burst, the 'reserve capital' of much of our banking system was wiped out and about 50% of the houses in the US went 'underwater'. So, we drained the financial capital lubricating oil out of the crankcase of our economic engine; the engine stopped; and millions of people in the US were seriously hurt.
Here's the situation: Banks will make loans on assets. But if the banks make enough loans on just some focused assets, then the asset values will rise which will let the banks make more loans on those assets, ..., and we blow a bubble. Then when the last loan is made, prices start to fall; the banks don't get paid back; the financial system dies; and the economy dies. So, really, don't want banks making loans on 'financial assets'. Well, for stocks, after the Great Depression, we stopped that. But with housing, essentially the same scam got started again, with the help of Fannie and Freddie.
Fannie and Freddie, along with the Federal Reserve, along with major parts of DC cheering it all on, were the real problem. The last time we did that, a wacko house painter and some of his buddies killed 50 million people, or maybe it was 100 million, I can't remember just exactly.
We shouldn't do such things. The media should keep us informed so that we don't.
As for even AIG getting a 'bailout', I don't quite agree with that. Yes, they did get a ton of money, on seemingly 'cheap terms', but the logic is the same. If the insurer of all these financial instruments can't honor it's contracts...imagine the implications for the economy as a whole. Not only would they be reneging on contracts, enshrined in law, but many firms that purchased all sorts of insurance (not just on CDOs) - GE, Walmart, etc - on various assets/products would instantly be SOL.
So even if you take just the financial firms and their tanglings there out of the picture, in terms of getting back 100 cents on the dollar on their CDS Swaps, if AIG can't honor ANY of their contracts at a time when companies (all throughout the country in hundreds of industries) are experiencing softer aggregate demand and falling revenue, just that alone would be catastrophic beyond anything we have ever seen.
So I don't see it as an 'AIG bailout', but rather saving the US economy. Besides, they will be able to recoup their investment once they finish selling the useful assets and repairing the balance sheet over the long term.
Also, it's not just Fannie and Freddie that are to blame - as Bernanke said the exhorbitant global imbalances with countries running massive current account surpluses that creates an incentive for investors to put money to work. China doesn't want it's $3T sitting in cash, even just $100B sitting in cash could cost China about $2B - $10B/year depending on where it is sitting (just in inflation alone). So the pressure to at least do something to protect it against inflation is immense and that's just China.
Suffice it to say, there are many factors (from the mortgage tax credit to Fannie & Freddie to global imbalances to misaligned incentives on Wall St.) that are to blame. The damn media likes to play on the most populist and it's annoying.
One of the things I can say, is that I am impressed that people like Bernanke and Paulson can hold their nose and go against EVERYTHING they believe in (i.e. non-intervention in markets) and everything they have been taught and learned over their entire professional careers and completely violate these beliefs in a matter of days/weeks. It's easy to sit on the sidelines and vilify these people for their actions, when you don't quite understand the implications of non-action and even how tough it was for them to make those decisions. The fact is, these people ignored their beliefs and acted in the country's interest.
I am not even American and I can admire their actions.
Edit 1: To put their actions into perspective, it's the equivalent of being a 'pro-lifer' your entire life and in order to save the entire country you have to personally sanction wide-scale abortions. How many people would be able to do that? Might be a little dramatic, but I believe the parallels are similar.
I was 100% for the AIG 'loan' for just the reasons we both explained. But since it was not clear that AIG would ever be able to pay back all the loan, I was willing to call the loan at least in part a 'bailout', that is, 'help' or a 'gift' that might not get repaid.
It's too bad the media wants to use the Paulson, Bernanke, etc. excellent efforts to save the US and most of the world as a source of a coveted scandal by screaming "bailout", but, again, I fully agree with you that what the US did for (with) AIG was just essential.
I will insert: The stuff about a 'balanced budget amendment' and, much worse, Ron Paul's desire for essentially a gold standard instead of a Fed, would mean that there would be no Federal 'lender of last resort' which would force us back to the results we got in the 1930s when we were far too afraid to print money until people started shooting at us.
In addition we would not be able to fight any major wars at all; we might as well shut down most of the DoD.
Paul seems to believe that the Fed is the cause of all bubbles and that with a gold standard we would have no bubbles; history clearly shows otherwise. Even with a gold standard, there still is 'fractional reserve banking' and the possibility of bubbles, crashes, financial 'panics', etc. As I recall the history, at one point J. P. Morgan personally saved the financial system, and that situation was much of the motivation for creating the Federal Reserve.
Moreover, I'd go farther: A comparatively few bucks would have kept Lehman afloat long enough mostly to 'unwind' slowly. That is, there is a good chance that Lehman was mostly the victim of a 'run on their bank', some of it urged on by some short sellers. Sure, I would have expected that the Lehman stockholders would still have lost their shirts, but keeping Lehman going for their 'counter parties' might have greatly reduced the effects that gave us the Great Recession. Houses would still have gone underwater, CMOs and CDSs would still have been in trouble, but some of the intensity and volatility would have been reduced. Alas, the media was so eager to scream 'bailout' that it would have been politically too hot to 'save' Lehman, even if all the owners lost all.
For Paulson and Bernanke going against their beliefs, that shouldn't be too difficult! No one should ever have taken all that simple minded stuff as always 100% true anyway! Besides, Bernanke was a leading Great Depression scholar. Also, Paulson saw instantly the threat of 'bank runs' and 'cascading contagion'.
I do fault Greenspan for drinking too much Ayn Rand Russian Kool-Aid! Of course eventually he admitted before Congress that his belief that the firms would do the right things was expecting too much.
I do have some remaining questions: (1) I can understand what Country Wide and Fannie and Freddie did. But I don't fully understand the other flows, e.g., through the ratings agencies and the 'tranches' and to the CMOs and their CDSs with AIG, etc. I don't have any good data on how much of the paper was held in small banks, large banks, outside the US, or where. Just why the problems were mostly just in Florida, Arizona, Nevada, and California but not the rest of the US I don't get. Just why the problems in just those four states did so much damage to housing and the economy nearly everywhere in the US I don't get. Just what happened to routine commercial banking and why I don't have either good data or good understanding. (2) Actually there were some surprisingly similar housing bubbles outside the US, at least in Australia. So just how the US housing bubble made it to Australia I don't get. Then Canada was largely immune; just why Australia got sick but Canada didn't I don't get.
We should ALL have GOOD data and answers to these and other questions and should have had all along during the bubble blowing over the past 10 years. We didn't. At least this time we're not at much risk of a Hitler, but we've come close and are not fully out of the woods yet.
As for Ron Paul's abolition of the Fed, I couldn't agree more. It's a bunch of crock. All you have to do is look at the history of recessions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_Unite...
I mean...really, the longest time period between recessions in that approx 90 years (1836 - 1926) was 5 years. Imagine that, literally...over other year (almost) America had a recession. That's batshit crazy.
Is THAT what we want to go back to? Fractional reserve banking and central banking is the damn cure to all of that.
Ron Paul is off his knockers when he talks about this stuff, and the most painful part is that so many people listen to him. They don't know any better.
As for your questions, as far as I understand it, the housing bubble CDOs were just the tip of the iceberg. When I lived in FL, there were many small community banks, that went bust because they held tons of CDOs backed up by subprime car loans and credit cards - YES!!! These guys were insane.
As for Canada, the truth is, I don't quite get that one either...because as far as I know, the 'standard' mortgage up there is actually a variable rate. I haven't done much research into it, but I have a few friends that live up there and are goin through the house-buying phase now. It's so bad that we had a debate about whether 30-year fixed mortgages even exist anywhere in the world. I kindly linked him to the relevant US regulators that explicitly show rates on up to 40-year fixed. He was flabbergasted. So, I honestly don't know what's happening over there.
I agree that we should know, I am sure the data is there...I have just been busy trying to keep my startup dreams alive (no time to do all that research - as much as I would love to).
Yes, one of the reasons a bank had architecture borrowed from some ancient Greek temple was to convince depositors that the bank was 'solid' and not about to go bust, which long far too many banks did.
The PBGC is capped at $54k/year and no benefits. The government would not have had to pay for retirees health benefits (often described as "gold-plated"), and only would have had to pay for part of their pensions.
http://www.pbgc.gov/wr/benefits/guaranteed-benefits.html
Also, in the event of bankruptcy, secured bondholders would have been paid before unsecured union benefits. The bailout was circumventing the rules of bankruptcy in order to minimize damage to the UAW. I wonder why?
Same thing with your China implication, that they wouldn't be where they were without the US media distorting information... that just doesn't make sense to me. Please explain if you can
The uranium from Niger was maybe not real after all but even if real likely not very important: As I recall, that uranium chemical is a standard industrial item. E.g., one use of uranium is to color plastic lenses for cars or some such. Getting uranium is not so tough; enriching it enough for a bomb is. Running a uranium reactor is not so tough; getting the plutonium, 239 as I recall, and don't want 240 or some such, is tougher. Then to separate the plutonium, use just chemical means. Then to compress it enough to have a critical mass is tricky and likely needs some testing, and tests are now essentially impossible to hide.
The media should have helped make it clear that the evidence that Saddam was close to any very serious WMDs was very thin stuff.
W invaded Iraq on very thin stuff. The media should have made that fact very clear to the voters.
Okay, maybe we should have dumped Saddam. Maybe. I would have tried making him an offer he couldn't refuse, but maybe we're not supposed to do that. So, maybe we should have dumped him.
Getting to Baghdad took, what, 23 days? Then the big mistake started: Bremer decided to do 'nation building'. And his first step was to fire the Iraqi army -- dumb, dumb, dumb. Nearly every common thug criminal, gang leader, organized crime leader, terrorist leader, out of work soldier, Shiite leader, Sunni leader, Kurdish leader, Iranian politician, etc. saw how dumb it was and took advantage. Nearly the only one in Iraq who didn't 'get it' was Bremer.
Our media didn't keep us informed.
On China, it's simple: Our media didn't keep us informed. We still don't know the actual flows. First cut we need to know the flows.
Sometimes the media is silent; sometimes they pay attention to an important topic but make a mess, out of bias or just sloppy work; often they assume that the audience wouldn't want to know; usually it's just a lot cheaper to do sloppy reporting. Whatever, we're, net, getting the mushroom treatment from the media -- keep us in the dark and feed us BS.
Actually likely and apparently quite a lot of quite solid information is available. Likely a lot of it is on the Internet. I keep looking and hoping to find good sources although finding them is not my full time job.
I upchuck at FOX, NYT, LAT, WaPo, ABC, CBS, NBC, MSNBC, CNN, PBS, and about everything else I can find. Law, medicine, engineering, etc. -- in none of these do we try to get by with the mushroom treatment we get from the media. If an airplane were designed with the information quality of the media, then it'd never get off the ground which, net, would be a good thing.
My concern is not partisanship but stupidity.
As voting citizens, we need solid information. With solid information, there's no way we'd be in the mess of The Great Recession or two wars each 10 years old.
http://xkcd.com/980/huge/#x=-10540&y=-4650&z=6
$700 billion was made available. "Only" $400 billion of this was actually spent. It was used to buy so-called toxic assets. Many of those assets were later converted back into cash: half of the $400 billion has already been repaid. Based on the value of the remaining assets, after they get sold and the money returned to the pot, it looks like the cost of TARP will be about $42 billion. That's a lot of money, but far from $1 trillion.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_public_debt Look at the debt expansion which is necessary to directly funnel the money to the banks.
The money goes from the Govt to the Fed who lends it to banks via the discount window, IIRC the rate for the discount window is still 0. The Fed still holds $2 trillion in assets which is up from $500 million pre-2008, there's the $1.2 trillion (and a bit more). The TARP verbiage is just a smoke screen because that's where people will look, so they moved it to the discount window.
I think the graphs over at ZeroHedge that come from Bloomberg terminals are a tad bit more accurate than XKCD, that's just my opinion though.
Who knew?
When the Fed lent money to the banks via the discount window, they did that to shore up the capital bases of the various financial institutions. The Treasury never paid for it....matter of fact, the argument can be made that if inflation runs away like doomsayers have been predicting since QE1, the Treasury will benefit - because inflation is simply a tax on the poor.
But, inflation has been subdued, despite constant harranging from doomsayers, and growth has been tepid. The Fed took on over $2T onto it's balance sheet because it is the only organization in the world that can. It wasn't up from $500M, it was up from $500B. You were off by only a factor of 1,000. So it only swelled 4X....considering that the price of not doing that would have been a great depression that made the depression of the 40s look like a mild recession, I would say it's worth every penny.
Also, the reason public debt has expanded is because of the borrowing the government has had to do to finance things like increased unemployment insurance, increased medicare/medicaid claims and tax cuts for everybody.
Also, because interest rates have been at all-time lows...i.e. most investors still see US Treasuries as the safest asset around (comparatively speaking).
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-11-28/secret-fed-loans-un...
It doesn't necessarily require throwing more money, in aggregate, at the education space. May mean spending less, but smarter. Lots of free ways to learn between the Internet, public libraries, family, neighbors, the physical opportunities of the world around us, and life itself. Helping more people to have better focus and willpower, and better emotional balance, and health, would go a long way to improving a lot of other things with the economy, even if indirectly.
For example, given a choice between having 1 more fellow citizen become a scientist or engineer, or instead having 10 more fellow citizens not steal, hurt people, be lazy, lack the ability to think logically, be swayed by propaganda when voting, lack ability to manage their own money, lack ability to plan for their future and understand consequences of their choices, and understand the impacts of their choices on their children, family, neighbors, future generations, etc -- I'll take the second option, please.
More "higher" education? Good. Much better "lower" education? Ten times as good, I bet.
I understand your frustration with the way the economy has performed (or not) in the last 2 years, and the seeming 'cronyism' that Obama has enacted - but the fact remains that if he didn't do what he did...we wouldn't even be having this discussion now. There is no telling what state the US would be in, after the rioting and such.
I know it's hard to envision, but believe me....rioting on a wide scale and massive police crackdowns (on a scale America has never seen) could not be ruled out.