You can have both if you keep the PR branches
|
*
|\
| *
| |
| *
|/
*
|\
| *
|/
|
Each PR is neatly delineated, and I can quickly follow things at coarse-grained level (follow only the left parents; there's even a `git log` flag for this) or at a fine-grained level.This isn't just pretty -- this has been actively helpful to me many, many times. I can `git bisect` into a merged PR to more precisely identify where an issue arose, and `git rebase` onto intermediate commits instead of jumping all the way to the end if I find a whole PR to be problematic to rebase past in one go.
It's XKCD's "My code's compiling!" for 2022.
Of course, if you have an organization-wide monorepo, this isn't going to work. (At the same time, at that point, you should probably be a bit more selective about what CI you run based on what components have changed... and make decisions about what checks to run nightly rather than on PRs.)