Hacker News Reader

Comment by AdriaanvRossum | Hacker News Reader

> It's important to understand that one of the main intentions of Chartist is to rely on standards rather than providing it's own solution to a problem which is already solved by those standards.

This is a great intention. Let the browser solve the issues that already have solutions. Well done.

View on HN

A great intention all else being equal. Unfortunately all else is not equal in this case. They say other libraries use "the wrong technology" (canvas). In my opinion this uses the wrong technology. SVG is much slower than canvas as soon as you have a few thousand points.

This might be fine for very small graphs but canvas is better in general.

I believe SVG and canvas both have strengths, and weaknesses, and should be used where it makes the most sense for each technology. When it comes to charts, SVG has an obvious benefit in that it comes with responsiveness built-in, and is far easier to style (and animate) via CSS. More importantly, but rarely mentioned, SVG is far more accessibility-friendly than the canvas element[1].

That said, I was also surprised by the assertion "use the wrong technologies for illustration (canvas)". It takes a lot more work, but canvas based charts can be made to be responsive, interactive and accessible[2][3].

[1] - CSS-tricks article on SVG and accessibility - https://css-tricks.com/accessible-svgs/

[2] - I outlined how someone could build a charting library based on my JS canvas library in a couple of lessons starting here - https://scrawl-v8.rikweb.org.uk/learn/eighth-lesson/

[3] - The final result from the above lessons can be seen here - https://codepen.io/kaliedarik/project/editor/AMVKPx - suggested improvements to the lessons, and the UX of the result, are always welcome.

I've been using Chartist for the last couple of years for line charts. The ability to style with CSS has been a useful benefit. For example, I have dark/light mode just by setting a class on the body element of the page and this flows throughout the site including the graphs with no extra effort.

I tend to agree. Canvas is a more direct route to leveraging the GPU.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com