Now there are too many people trying to live close to available jobs, agriculture has mechanized meaning there are fewer jobs in rural locations, America industrialised then peaked and de-industrialised a bit, companies are automating processes. All these changes, I don't think you can confidently point to regulation as a single or primary issue.
Rather than look that far to the past, it would probably be better to identify policy that can help in the present and future. Sure, the past can provide lessons, but we can't idealize it or just transfer what worked when there were only 9 million people in the USA.