I don't know - an hour out of Penn Station takes you as far as places like Wyandanch on Long Island with the LIRR, or Stamford, CT with the MNR.
After all, you'd have to compare the outskirts of Stamford with the outsirkts of Tokyo.
If you take the Harlem Line up to the middle of nowhere, you can get to Katonah in an hour on the express trains during peak hours.
Going to Stamford is maybe like 1 hour, with frequent catastrophic delays and problems, such that we can maybe model it as like 1.5hr +/- 20 minutes, whereas an hour on a Japanese train is like 1.01hr +/- 30 seconds.
Wildly different user experiences.