It is not the "tech. departments" making the decisions.
It is a PHB [1] in the "security department" following a checklist of "recommended practices" and one of the checkboxes on the list is "add SMS 2FA".
I.e., you are looking at it as a technical decision where the pros and cons security wise are weighed and the better technical solution is selected.
Which is not at all how these decisions occur in the real world in real businesses, and esp. in stodgy ones like banks/finance. Instead the decision is driven not by technical merit but by what "options" are provided on the checklist they must follow, that checklist often being sourced from whatever govt. regulator provides their oversight.
The technical people building the solutions likely know all the problems, but are powerless to do anything but implement the directed solution, because the directed solution is the only one available on the "checklist" from which they are allowed to select.
[1] PHB = Pointy Haired Boss -- Dilbert cartoon reference