Gratuitous Space Battles (if pay more than average)
Gave Story+ (if pay more than average)
Jamestown
Bit.Trip Runner
Super Meat Boy
Shank
NightSky HD
Avg currently 4.70 (was 4.64 about 1 minute ago! climbing fast, damn HN!)
If the number of purchases so far were small, it's possible that buying several copies at $.01 would bring the average down by more than the cost in penny purchases (this is a strategy for a purely hypothetical selfish person with time to spend, but not $5). I expect the amount to fluctuate above and below $5.