The interesting thing about "elevator" algorithms is that they're really very similar to the algorithms used to schedule reads and writes on a hard drive. Reading in some data is similar to picking up a person, and writing data can be thought of as dropping the person off somewhere. Regular (i.e., not solid state) hard drives have large cylinders of addresses. This is sort of like a rolled up building.
I don't have the output in front of me, but I think that both LOOK [1] and SCAN [2] algorithms performed very well. It's cool to note that the SCAN algorithm is referred to as the "Elevator algorithm" by Wikipedia. Clearly we're not the first to go down this rabbit hole.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LOOK_algorithm [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elevator_algorithm