This allows them to increase average rates and maintain low lending volume, under the cover of credit scores that appear low in historical context. When it behooves them to begin lending again, their lending to people with low(-in-historical-context) credit scores will be paraded about as virtue.
There is simply no-one who is that far removed from a black sheep or friend/family member who's fallen on hard times. Not even during good economic times. Certainly not given the way people friend one another on these sites.
Any grading of people based on social connections will drag nearly everyone down, potentially in a self-reinforcing cycle.(higher rates push more people into worse economic situations, lowering their credit score, reflecting negatively on their friends who now pay higher rates, etc)