For those of us on maintenance teams, who actually have to dig in to the history to figure out what happened, not squashing matters a lot.
For those of us on maintenance teams, who actually have to dig in to the history to figure out what happened, not squashing matters a lot.
Other comments I made on another recent git post:
>One of those small typo fixes could introduce a bug and multiple commits makes it easier to track down. Blame would pinpoint it exactly - you'll see Bob's "Fix a typo" commit instead of being buried in Bob's "Add trucks to the game" commit. That saves you from having to go look at the PR or diff and to figure out why Bob renamed cares to cars.
Over the past few months we've been trying to formalize our git usage since we're split across a bunch of teams, and on this particular issue I've found a very hard split: People on the new-feature-development teams love squashing and squash-merge, people on the maintenance teams who have done work in git repos for a while are almost all against it (of the ones with no opinion, several are still only working in svn repos so haven't had a chance to form an opinion), but most people on the maintenance teams don't really speak up about it so our company-wide guidelines remain heavily in the squash-merge camp.