An underrated topic. All unions are not made alike, and the laws dictating European unions are very, very different than those in the US.
Yes. US unions are very different from European unions. Without getting into the details, US unions can be very destructive, while European unions are far more wholistic or cooperative.
To be clear, this is not about union members. It's about union leadership and the "mafia" how they do business. Union members are along for the ride, are sold entire narratives they have to support and can end-up losing big. Entire industries have been seriously damaged by our unions.
Source: I was in a union for about a decade. In addition to this, I have had this conversation with members of other unions, some of them as post-mortems after years of union damage caused job losses to China and, ultimately, the companies they worked for to shut down.
Solution? I can't think of a single simple idea. These are engrained cultural things. People rarely wake up to the reality of what's going on until the are suffering, take the time to think it through and ultimately realize where the pain came from.
Of course, in the US it's also become a huge political thing.
That's harder to implement in a more individualistic society like the US, and the history of violent union busting surely didn't help either.
Also in the EU there is internal competition between countries for construction projects that brings costs down overall. Unions in Germany jacking up your costs? Maybe there's a construction company in Poland or Czechia willing to do it for less. In Austria I see many construction sites are full with companies from Slovenia.
US labor laws focuses on all or nothing union control of a workplace. And once they have control, they get a lot of legal power.
Europe has a different model where unions do not have to have any sort of majority vote to be recognized. As such, membership tends to be more fluid. So the unions themselves have less specific control, but the unions can be larger, and be more recognized without as much antagonization.
Also, US unions have a lot of power over healthcare in the US. Usually being a function of the state in Europe, there's a lot less cost at stake when dealing with a European union.
So I think it's largely an apples to oranges comparison.
But when was the last time a major public U.S. union went on strike? Whereas French railway workers do it all the time.
If you’re talking about power along a single axis that alone makes the French unions significantly more powerful.
If unions get their way, why would they need to go on strike? The French go on strike because their unions don't always get their way.
Not saying they are all 100% bad but the big anti-union push and negative perception is not some pay-op like some people seem to think it is. It is based on assessing their behaviour and for many deciding it is quite unreasonable.
There's even a German word, "Warnstreik," that refers to a short strike (as short as a few hours) carried out just to send a warning to company management that the union means business.
The unions in the transit sector are extremely active in Germany and France. As we speak, Paris is at standstill because of a massive transit strike.[0]
0. https://www.rfi.fr/en/france/20221110-unions-warn-of-indefin...
Unless the threat is exercised every once in a while, it is not taken seriously.
German and French companies know that unions are capable of and willing to go on strike if their demands are not met. That gives companies a much larger incentive to make concessions.
The Warnstreiks I mentioned earlier are a tool for reminding companies every once in a while that the possibility of a strike exists. They're often used during contract negotiations, when the union doesn't feel the company is giving enough.
The last rail strike was adverted at the last moment, like it often is, so I suspect the railroad union is not weak.
The teacher's unions very rarely strike, they must be very weak?
It seems, however, that teachers are getting fed up, and there's finally been a bit more strike activity by teachers in the US over the last 4 years.