What makes an artifact okay to own versus illicitly trafficked? A government permit from the time it was excavated?
Whether it's illegal to own one of these artifacts is going to vary. Some countries have laws that make it illegal, but many don't. It's usually always impossible to legitimately sell these artifacts, since you can't show provenance (and if you could, the provenance would show that they were stolen). Just like stolen art can't be sold—even after many years and owners—trafficked artifacts can't be sold either.