I've always felt it was a shitty policy, it has been exploited countless, even more so in time sensitive situations. But that is the requirement as it stands now and no company is going to challenge it as a failure in attempt is far more harmful to them, than taking down someone else problematic content.
> The DMCA safe harbor provisions only apply to claims of copyright infringement. Therefore, they do not provide any protection against trademark claims, whether for trademark infringement, trademark dilution, or cybersquatting.
If the FTC has the authority I’d love to see them bring the hammer down on big tech for stuff like this. A $100 million fine for destroying someone’s small business would be fine by me.
1. https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/trademark-user-generated-co...
But yes, I think the Dmca system is flawed greatly without a serious punishment for those who abuse it.
This smells similar to the Fortnite / Apple dustup, and the end result of that wasn't that Apple was forced to re-list Fortnite in their App Store; it was that [edit: my mistake; misremembered] Apple was barred from retaliating against Epic but the only way to play Fortnite (legally) on Apple hardware now is through Microsoft's cloud service.
I don't know what legal precedent would force Google to list an app in their (obviously large and market-dominant) private store that they wholly own.