But if an exchange claims that they hold your crypto 'frozen' and completely separate from their trading activities, and especially if the exchange also deal in government currency, then I think it's quite right for government to regulate, and ensure the exchanges are compliant.
I think from a purist perspective that is true. I said this upthread but what people really want is more USD in their checking account. These exchanges are a place where they can roll the dice and maybe make that happen. As I said before, i bet 95% of the people burned couldn't care less about the philosophical aims of crypto currencies and just want a chance to get rich (in USD).
The purists care about independence from government but they also don’t like centralized exchanges so they don’t care if they are regulated.
The other people are in for the gamble rather than the fundamentals of crypto. A certified casino is probably more trustworthy to them.
As long as the government doesn’t try to regulate the chain, both groups are satisfied.
Maybe what's better and cheaper is to let this wild west "enjoy being poor" nonsense flame out until everyone shoots themselves and it's curtains.
It will sort of be like Usenet - it didn't go anywhere but you have to know how to find it.