Hacker News Reader

Comment by erwincoumans | Hacker News Reader

That's cool! Like playing classic Doom inside Doom 3. Is there a list of games that let you play older versions from within?

View on HN

The adventure game "Day of the Tentacle" had the previous version of "Maniac Mansion" included. According to Wikipedia [1] it was the first time you could play the predecessor game in a newer version.

  The whole original Maniac Mansion game can be played on a 
  computer resembling a Commodore 64 inside the Day of the Tentacle 
  game; this practice has since been repeated by other game 
  developers, but at the time of Day of the Tentacle's release, it 
  was unprecedented.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day_of_the_Tentacle

I played Maniac Mansion the first time that way. I never got it originally, but played Day of the Tentacle and got side tracked finishing that game inside the game.

You can play Wolfenstein 3D in one of the recent Wolfenstein games. IIRC it's presented as an arcade machine, but it seemed like the whole game was there (I played quite a bit of it, but didn't finish before bailing back out to the "real" game).

Tried to find a TVTropes for this kind of thing, but couldn't. Surprised, seems like there'd be one.

it predates TVTropes (Shakespeare did it), and it's called "a play-within-a-play"

https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ShowWithinAShow

Well, right, but that's not quite the same thing. Video games also do "show within a show", sometimes taking the form of an actual show (Address Unknown in Max Payne, and that other one that's plainly mimicking Lynch's Invitation to Love from Twin Peaks), or an actual play, as in Midsummer Night's(? I think it has the one with Thisby and such, right?) or Hamlet, which I wanna say at least one Final Fantasy has featured (9?), among other games, or sometimes, matching the medium, taking the form of minigames (dice or card games, or arcade games, say, in games that aren't primarily about those things but just have them in the world—even sports games in non-sports games, like Blitzball from FFX)

The purest form of this specific thing is more like having an entire episode of MASH play on a TV in the background during an episode of Trapper, MD.

There's also the linked "Game Within a Game" article linked from the above article: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/GameWithinAGame or the "Embedded Precursor" which is more specific about the embedded game: https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/EmbeddedPrecurso...

Ah, embedded precursor is the right one. I tried to find the relevant page by looking through the lists of tropes for a couple that feature that, and failed.

If you bring DOTT to Scummvm, you'll get the two games.

I'm not sure if there's a list, but a notable example of this is Day of the Tentacle, the sequel to Maniac Mansion.

In the game there is a computer, which if you interact with it, allows you to play the entire original Maniac Mansion.

Fun, didn't know that. I recall both games, Maniac Mansion on C=64. Impossible Mission is the first game I recall with working terminals inside (but those terminals didn't play a full game although it likely could be done).

Not quite an older version of itself, but the original Animal Crossing on Gamecube had a whole NES emulator built in, with several games available.

https://animalcrossing.fandom.com/wiki/NES_Games

This was such a genius idea. As a kid who grew up poor, this gave me access to a number of games I would never gotten to play.

I wish more games did this.

Not economical anymore, if you can instead slowly trickle them out to your paying subscribers at two games a month, to then end up at 10% of the library your previous console had when you discontinue it.

Not older versions of the game itself, but the entire gimmick of Lazy Jones is that you're an employee walking around a building and entering rooms to goof off playing mini-versions of various games on a lot of different computers:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7DyoDJCqac

I guess it sort-of doesn't really count, since the "games within the game" are essential parts of the game itself.

Donkey Kong 64 had the original arcade Donkey Kong.

Celeste lets you play the classic PICO-8 version in a secret room.

Super Mario Brothers 3 had the original (non-"Super") Mario Brothers arcade game embedded in it. (If the second player tried to visit the same spot as the first player on the map, it would jump to the arcade game like a little competitive mini-game.)

GoldenEye 007 has a fully functional ZX Spectrum emulator with several Rare games: https://www.therwp.com/forums/showthread.php?t=48139

If I recall, you could play Crash Bandicoot in one of the Uncharted games (both made by Naughty Dog).

Uncharted 4: A Thief's End. It's not the whole game, IIRC, but a few levels here and there.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com