Does Wall St include people directly invested in equity and debt markets via 401k/IRA/defined benefit (DB) pensions/etc and indirectly via being taxpayers of jurisdictions that have taken on those DB pension liabilities?
Does Wall St include people directly invested in equity and debt markets via 401k/IRA/defined benefit (DB) pensions/etc and indirectly via being taxpayers of jurisdictions that have taken on those DB pension liabilities?
What I’m curious about is what component of inflation is the fact even with shipping rates dropped a ton they’re still twice what they were pre pandemic and fuel costs, which drives a marginal cost of any physical good, being so high? Maybe it’s a war disrupting energy prices and food?
Inflation is caused when demand is higher than supply can meet. Given the worlds ability to produce JIT it feels implausible that supply can’t meet demand if inflation were just left alone. I don’t know that making everyone poorer to reduce demand is the right answer. Maybe just let inflation happen for a while and keep capital cheap so we can invest rapidly in expanding supply?
Just as you can not deliver a baby in one month with 9 pregnant women, you can not grow food faster than it takes.
Also, there is no "leaving alone". As a central bank, you have to choose an interest rate, and this affects bond yields, stock prices, and financing costs (such as to produce said food).
Leaving alone in what I said means “don’t mess with the cost of capital and let people borrow to expand supply as fast as we can.” Eventually as we grow capacity to produce and people compete for higher prices we will overshoot supply, a consolidation will occur, and prices will drop. Trying to decrease supply expansion by making it more expensive to borrow to fund expansion will not improve supply. It will indirectly reduce demand by inducing savings and inducing a decrease in economic activity and a recession and unemployment, and therefore suffering.
I mostly agree. We see a clear supply problem right now. China's covid lockdowns mean any new iPhone Pro ordered today will not be here until next year.
There is no "just a while". Once it starts it's hard to stop. They're trying to save the dollar (and everything with a dependency on it).
There is just a while by the way. Increasing interest rates is a very indirect way to manage inflation. You essentially stimulate savings and increase the cost of growth by making capital more expensive and makes services that depend on warehouse credit more expensive to operate. Stimulating savings decreases spending which decreases economic activity which decreases demand and makes supply exceed demand and prices drop. But it also means less economic activity, which translates into unemployment, lack of wage growth, and other factors. But this process takes time, just like supply expansion through cheap capital (low interest rates). It’s also really hard to reverse a recession while it’s easy to stop a boom.
I’d rather stuff become more expensive for a while and keep my job and get raises to account for it while the economy expands to meet demand than lose my job and have absolutely nothing and struggle to make ends meet while we stumble through a recession, especially since inflation will keep going for some time despite the recession.
I know recession definitely do, and they’re a heck of a lot easier to stop than periods of growth.
I think frenetically switching monetary policy based on a relatively short trend is probably bad no matter what.
Your statement about making everyone poorer to reduce demand is confusing. Do you mean raising interest rates makes everyone poorer and we shouldn't do it? If so, that's not true. It makes people that have borrowed poorer and it makes people who have lent richer. There are second order effects where borrowers can no longer borrow and spend so demand is reduced but that's not really making people poorer, it's limiting their ability to spend money they don't have. If you meant inflation was making everyone poorer, that's true, but your statement doesn't come off that way. Raising prices broadly makes everyone poorer, which is why the central bank should be fighting inflation with whatever tools they have.
Back to the limitless JIT production. if that was true (and we had limitless delivery to where goods were needed) then yah, we wouldn't have inflation, I agree. What we have instead is high production capabilities that took a hit from the war and a much larger hit from Covid policies messing up factory production and all this being fed into a severely overloaded transport system with chokepoints at most ports causing backlogs. if you want the high JIT production and delivery to be true then you need to address the causes of it not being true and that is often (but not always) government. Government is standing in the way of breaking the unions and automating the ports, for example. Government is also standing in the way of new fossil fuel infrastructure that is desperately needed via extreme uncertainty in regulatory approval processes.
If the issue is supply can’t meet demand, you can either reduce spending or demand and increase savings or you can make capital expansion cheaper and encourage supply meeting demand. The former makes everyone poorer because the economy shrinks. The latter grows the economy, and makes everyone richer.
Now I agree inflation is bad for everyone. But inducing a global recession is an ass backwards way to solve it. Expanding supply capacity and ability to deliver while reducing frictional cost of transportation solves it in a positive way.
But either way won’t see results over night. It takes time for any of this to happen. But I’ll argue here that inducing a recession and economic downturn by rewarding saving and not spending leaves us at a worse place in 10 years than we would have been had we grown into the demand and rewarded capital expansion in the face of increasing demand.
Note, I know there’s a morality in our culture around spending and saving as a concept, but I think these are entirely specious. You should save regardless of the reward structure to provide stability and a buffer against turbulence, and being parsimonious is IMO the actual moral imperative. Saving and spending in the above isn’t necessarily at an individual level but at a societal level. Saving is necessarily contracting economic activity by making capital expensive and removing currency from exchange for goods and services, and creating artificial incentives to save will lead to misery - layoffs, shrinking economic activity, declines in equity markets and the value of real goods relative to savings, etc, all of which is not beneficial to anyone in the long run.
Inflation, unless followed on with expansion of currency to try to battle inflation, will resolve itself naturally either way. But letting supply and demand work out the price in the market and making capital cheap means more people and businesses will try to capture more of that extra demand. That’s good isn’t it? Usually markets overshoot so you would ultimately see a period of deflation, especially if a recession pops out, undoing the experienced inflation.
But creating a recession to make people spend less and therefore decrease expansion and opportunity for growth is a truly awful strategy.
2. You confuse money with stuff. Generally, more stuff makes people richer, not more money. More money when there isn't enough stuff makes inflation.
3. More spending is currently how we measure growth but it's dangerous and incorrect to label growth coming from spending. Savings drives capital accumulation and capital drives efficiency gains/production gains, which means more ability to produce more stuff. It is easy to make this error because there are tons of things we can do that destroys the capital stock but drives spending in the near term to great medium/long term detriment.
second paragraph: 4. This whole thing is basically wrong. Making credit cheaper only "solves" the problem if the credit expansion can grow the output of whatever the constraint(s) is(are) faster than it is growing demand for the constraint itself. This is both not gauranteed and not likely in this case given we were already basically at the zero bound interest rate and funding all sorts of insane startup ideas/company largess at the large companies. Higher interest rates reign in malinvestment, which is definitely happening right now and destroying demand from malinvestment is a very good thing.
Third paragraph: 5. Do you think the economy wasn't trying to self correct in the way you describe and failing prior to interest rates being tightened? We had very extended and worsening inflation from the exact strategy you describe before the central bank finally flipped to tightening. If this actually worked we wouldn't be here.
Fourth paragraph: 6. This is impossible to agree on because I would say the places that have taken this path to its logical conclusion ended in hyperinflation and economic death spiral and you will say those places weren't really trying what you propose.
Fifth paragraph onward: 7. I obviously strongly disagree with you for non moral reasons so I don't see a lot of value addressing your morality arguments.
In my perspective, the bailout has been happening for decades, every time the federal government steps in to prevent broad market prices from substantially declining.
Not only have politicians been keeping labor costs low by using high ROI assumptions, they have been underfunding DB pension plans even with those rosy assumptions providing low costs for budgeting purposes.
For this reason, I think it is safe to assume the government will backstop equity prices over the long term (5+ years). It would not be politically popular amongst the voting population to let them fall.
https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/articles/...
People get what they want, and it's still not good. In this case, triumph of labor, high wage growth, low employment, and rentiers scurrying to eek out any kind of gain.
Do you mean low unemployment?