Hacker News Reader

Totally get that. And I think if those are the conventions you're designing form interactivity with then, absolutely, you probably need a javascript library to validate and step your user through form submission.

My point is that this should be the exception, not the rule. I certainly don't think this level of abstracted complexity is necessary, or even better, in most scenarios. I'm talking at a design or implementation level.

View on HN

Many people are significantly less technically savvy than you might expect. Every form really needs all of these conventions if you want to make your software as widely usable as possible (which is all consumer software at least, or should be).

So in fact I think it is the rule, not the exception.

Unfortunately you have to do a dumb JS dance to get these reasonable affordances. Hard to blame people for not reimplementing all this shit even if it’s critically useful for many folks.

I'll have to respectfully disagree. Not with your first sentence, that's true enough, but everything else.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com