It has been multiyear battles to get their "official scientific consensus) moved off things like "eggs are bad" and now finally "meat is bad". Glad to see there's progress being made. Also glad I got out of that field.
It has been multiyear battles to get their "official scientific consensus) moved off things like "eggs are bad" and now finally "meat is bad". Glad to see there's progress being made. Also glad I got out of that field.
My wife is in the process of transferring her international nutrition degree to the US, and we learned that starting in Jan 2024, nutritionists will now need a Masters degree to be eligible for accreditation.
Talk about pulling up the drawbridge behind you...
Anyways, I'm not complaining about it being hard or complicated, I'm complaining about it being low quality and corrupt. For instance: https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2016/09/13/493739074...
One thing about engineering is it can succeed or fail fairly quickly, and the results can mostly be replicated. We build a reactor and we soon know whether it works or not. And reactors are something we understand enough that we can design them, and create them.
Meanwhile in nutrition we're making educated guesses and watching what happens over decades. What helps one person kills another. We're using statistics to tease out the truth, to get mere glimpses of the truth. We're on the outside making educated guesses about a system beyond our full comprehension.
A final thought: Which will happen first: commercially viable fusion energy, or the obesity rate in the US falling below 25%? Which would you bet on? (I am considering the challenge of how to improve the diet and nutrition of an entire nation under the umbrella of "nutrition science" here.)
As other have noted in the comments, research into nutrition is often poorly distributed and implemented. It often over emphasizes child nutrition and neglects adult nutrition. And it is fraught with bad science and agendas.
This says nothing about how complex nutrition is compared to any other field of research.
If they acknowledged the complexity, there wouldn't have been a "Food Pyramid".