I don't think this is true. I think that people who are selling things generate hype for those things that they're selling, and our media not only depends on those sellers to pay for ads, but additionally is owned by people who are also invested in those things that are being sold.
I think this can easily be misinterpreted as everything being hyped up, rather than everything being designed to trick you into supporting things that benefit people who sell, whether they're politicians or toilet-brush sellers. This is happening because our politicians, toilet-brush sellers, and media are owned by the same people. They rely on you buying in, or at least not being able to organize or sustain an opposition. We've allowed the world to consolidate so much that separating sales and news is impossible. They're operating from the same address.
Main point: not everything is being hyped. Scams that benefit the people who own the media that hype spreads through are being hyped.
Speak for yourself, I was saying this guy was going to end up in black site prison in the Summer of '22 as CONbase was looking like it was going to be insolvent, SBF's meddling in the US political system just underscores the MO of the well-heeled of SV, VC and political circles. In many ways this represents what that class does in any ecosystem: it does it in the stock market, the energy market, pharmaceutical drugs, Ag seed IP etc... it's all just a means to an end.
Why weren't we having this conversation with memestocks and it's blatant collusion between the hedge fund World and regulators and even the Stock Market itself when it pulled the plug as it suffered too many one day loses? It almost makes me think this was intentional, a sort of deliberate narrative to push to ignore the blatant level of grift that is wide-spread in this economic system. The only question is cui bono?
> Main point: not everything is being hyped. Scams that benefit the people who own the media that hype spreads through are being hyped.
Yield farming was hyped in every conceivable manner, and it was HEAVILY resisted in the Bitcoin community because we had seen some variation of this before; Celcius and 3 arrows were also pushing this scam and were equally vilified at that time for the scam that they were, in fact when someone explained to me what Caradano was I felt it was just another MLM playing out in token form. I initially tried to talk people out, but I've been around long enough to know that getting burned is what it often takes for people to learn why this tech was invented in the first place.
People won't listen when everyone is getting paid as it feeds off of some basic Human urges: greed. It isn't until it all comes crashing down that people who once hailed as genius by the media or VC World in SV, likely paid to do so, are seen for the scammers that they are.
> This is happening because our politicians, toilet-brush sellers, and media are owned by the same people. They rely on you buying in, or at least not being able to organize or sustain an opposition. We've allowed the world to consolidate so much that separating sales and news is impossible. They're operating from the same address.
Well said, I highly recommend this series on the Murdoch's [0], I wasn't aware of how far Rupert's reach was in some key events in History (Berlin Wall, early 2000s Hong Kong) in order to sell a specific narrative, and I only vaguely recall how sensationalist his programming like 'A Current Affair' was at creating Fake News for sensationalism that drove sales.
Hell, it even seems like what Elon is doing at Twitter is exactly a page out of Murdoch's book with a paper he bought in the UK.
0: https://www.cnn.com/shows/the-murdochs-empire-of-influence
When I look at the writing and output from any particular text media journalist, particularly on the subject of many things related to global geopolitical issues, I ask myself, "is this something that would be seen as neutral and impartial, ethical journalism by Steve Coll?" [1]. Often the answer is no.
This requires knowing what you're talking about because, as OP alluded to, everyone is hyping everything, including acedemics and CEOs. In that enviroment, how does a jouranlist know who to talk to and what questions to ask? The only way in today's climate is to learn the subject, something which returns lower (perhaps negative) ROI vs posting clickbait hype content. "New startup claims quantom tech could crack your bank account password in just 3 seconds" will do better and requires less knowlege and effort than an a real investigation.
Somewhat, sure, but they aren't going to become an expert.
They are reporters. Journalists. They report what people do and say. They present their findings. Hopefully they find people that are willing to cast doubt on a subject, which in the case of crypto, they did. You had many articles from journalists reporting back on problems with crypto.
We pretend like FTX was something that was well known and well established, yet I didn't hear much about it here prior to everything collapsing. And suddenly, all these armchair experts come out the woodwork, apparently well aware of all the problems with FTX but apparently never spoke up once and didn't think it was news worthy. The experts are out there, but apparently none how how to talk to reporters.
> "New startup claims quantom tech could crack your bank account password in just 3 seconds" will do better and requires less knowlege and effort than an a real investigation.
Let's ignore all the "real investigations" that happen.
Logically I’d you’re covering some topic a reporter should seek out contrarian opinions. Not because they’re right, but because they provide another perspective.
They don’t even do that. Some article about crypto will just talk to crypto companies and fans.
But I suspect the real reason is article like “Some people like crypto and others don’t” doesn’t sell ad space.
Most people can't tell the differences between a reporter and an editor or a columnist. They are, like the parent commenter, ignorants on this matter. And yet they complain vigorously about something they don't even comprehend. It's fascinating if not terrifying.
FTX and Alameda didnt realise either. What makes you think that a journalist would have figured it out?
As for journalists - I'm not sure how exactly they would have known to discover this point. It seems obvious after the fact, but who would think to check "Let me make sure deposits actually go to the business I think they do"? Instead, what I mean here is that there were incredibly obvious signs of wrongdoing and I would expect that a critical and competent investigator would discover at least one such sign, write about it and be motivated to find more. That seems not to have happened which makes me think nobody was actually investigating a new startup with billions of dollars in an area rife with fraud - which seems like a pretty big condemnation for the class of people whose job is to investigate and analyze companies in that industry.
That's just wrong, article did a bit insinuating but never directly claimed that, and linked source (http://www.pkarchive.org/personal/EnronFAQ.html) actually disproves it:
> 1. What did I do? In early 1999 I was asked to serve on a panel that offered Enron executives briefings on economic and political issues. As far as I knew at the time, they genuinely wanted to learn something. I resigned from that board in the fall of 1999, when I accepted an offer to write for the New York Times.
It's funny to post such a clear falsehood when talking about Gell-Mann amnesia.
The modern corporate journalist's job is to know who and what to ask so propaganda can be constructed according to the wishes of the corporate-political complex.
This person paid fealty to the regime, ergo the job of journalists was to pump the scam and silence questions and concerns until the ruling class is not left holding the bag. Whereas if a billionaire fails to do those things, then the job is to find negative things to print and minimize the positive.
> Lack of skepticism and fact checking is, indeed, sins of the profession, but that's it.
On the contrary it is the very core of the profession, and it's how it's always been. The idea of the professional journalist as an impartial and unbiased truth seeker and reporter of news is itself propaganda.
“It’s a perfectly safe and normal procedure”.
Point being, I expect that at least some of the guests are arranged without much input from the hosts. There must be heavy politicking involved to get bandwidth in mass media, and the people actually doing the work (running interviews or writing articles) can only push back to the degree that they have some degree of control over the network or channel.
Plenty of what you read as “reporting”, which to the reader appears as actual news, is carefully planned corporate stories that are shopped around to various contacts in the media until someone bites. This is described as “organic media” (only because it’s not paid for), but it’s mostly directed by the companies themselves.
Not sure what these people were thinking I was doing with whatever I touched day-to-day.
Going through similar things with avian flu. "Experts" think I inhale raw chicken and that birds don't really care about borders. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/windsor/windsor-cfia-poultry-...
Or the assurances that the new food guide is no longer tainted by food/farming industries.
So while birds don't care about borders potential sick bird carcass does.
Avian flu is not great for farms, if there is a breakout you pretty much cannot have your birds outside. And if your flock is infected they will be gassed and destroyed which no one wants to happen. Hence why they are careful.
I worked with a newspaper and major publisher earlier in life and was shocked at how ignorant people that we read every day are on the very topics they are reporting on. Not to mention the abuse of alcohol and drugs that happens in the newsroom, which was baffling. The media does a lot better when it is looking at events and reporting on that rather than trying to derive some narrative or to get a scoop, especially when it involves business or government fluff. It doesn't help that a lot of journalists have what feels like a need for validation, but at the same time have big egos. All of these big scam artists know that and feed them.
The fourth estate is totally owned by the elites, and there is no real dissent with the views of the wealthy. That's why global warming is only now recognized at all (three decades late), because it is actually on some of their radars now.
I was just listening to some Christopher Hitchens videos yesterday and was reminded of just how articulate and elegant his arguments were.
Compare that to modern "intellectuals" like Jordan Peterson. Complete rabble rousers.
Social media has allowed cowardly arguments to be made mainstream and that has weakened our total global human B.S. detector by a ton.
Imagine crypto had to be popular without social media. It would have been ripped apart just like Marc Andreessen was ripped apart on that podcast for his intellectually vapid ideas.
It is really a shame how much harm social media has done to our species.
Do you have a better example?