There is a huge incentive to do things that people don’t actually want you doing, so someone can actually make money.
Accounting is just a word for tracking money.
It can be opaque, or obvious, detailed, or vague. And it can also be fake.
Knowing which is which, and if it is appropriate or not, is almost always specific to the circumstances and the goals of whoever is doing it, and that’s pretty fundamental.
GAAP is a generally acceptable list of practices for public entities, but there are still a ton of judgement calls going on there, and have to be, for what is a pretty ‘standard’ way to operate pretty standard businesses.
There is no automated way to do it that won’t allow manipulation.
Attempts at automating it are more likely to provide something like bank account statements, than a balance sheet. Which is something, but it’s not enough. That’s what is generally referred to as book keeping (aka transactions are recorded, but not necessarily characterized or organized correctly), but may even fall short of that.
They can make plenty of money through volume (fees), while holding the crypto 1:1. Sounds relatively easy to me.
That’s the baffling thing about FTX/Alameda. FTX on its own could be a nice profitable business, yet it seems they got greedy by lending customer funds to the hedge fund-y sister company.
And fees get competitive, it’s inevitably a race to the bottom, where firms need to spend a lot of money competing on things like long term reputation.
Meanwhile if they screw up in their security, they’re also liable for huge multiples of those fees in losses.
And if someone pops up that charges less fees, and seems ok enough, a lot of the money moves there quickly, until there is a scandal anyway.
It requires a mature organization who has strong controls and bulletproof working processes to avoid losing multiple years in fees by accident too.
Not saying you’re wrong - it’s where things inevitably end up when it’s heavily regulated and watched so all the other alternatives are hard (and result in major prison time). Usually.
But it should be noted that brick and mortar banks gave up on that model a very long time ago, favoring explicitly loaning out customer funds (fractional reserve banking) because it’s more sustainable for them.
Not really. Their tech stack was too slow so other Market Makers weren't willing to come over (the price can change and leave them fulfilling sales at bad prices too frequently). So they had Alameda be their market maker and they were constantly burning money doing that. Maybe they believed there would be enough liquidity if they scaled more and it was an investment in their future (a very charitable view) and it was fine to borrow funds in the short term and then that got away from them. But from what we've heard of their tech stack, they weren't ever going to be viable because they couldn't support what HFT would need.
You can only do that if you are holding exclusivly onto one asset. The relative values of different tokens change over time. So if you want 1:1, you need to have a robust mechanism for doing that.
But you won't want to because that'll burn through transaction fees for no real gain.
> FTX on its own could be a nice profitable business
That requires fees, and given the number of exchanges that do it for free, so long as you keep your wallet with them, its not going to make you money.
Sure you can do market making, or arbitrage, but that's still risky and you don't make that much money doing it. <0.1% on each transaction.
(Before that was available though, both lived entirely on fees, unless they've been committing massive fraud.)
We don’t know what Coinbase and Kraken are doing internally.
Coinbase does seem to be mostly off fees (which are sky high), and does seem not sketchy. It doesn’t appear overly easy for them even then (hence the ‘it’s hard’) despite folks being itching to put money in on the way up to the point they’ll mostly ignore high fees.
They’re definitely playing the long game, compared to the others that have looted billions elsewhere.
As the main on/off ramp in the US, they have a pretty nice position from it too.
That it was possible to do it differently earlier, and some folks did start transitioning, doesn’t change the fact that we don’t have much track record with it yet as ‘the way it is done’.
It usually takes decades for these things to stabilize into anything predictable.
So there are still a lot of unknown unknowns, including ‘what will the ecosystem look like when it is the majority’.
It might be lower on fraud. Or higher. Or economic to just stake. Or not.
We don’t know yet.
Staked ETH isn't available to be used for any other purpose, like paying transaction fees, depositing in defi protocols, using as currency, etc.
Anyway, this is getting a bit far afield of my point, which is just that for ETH, exchanges can earn money on deposits, without loaning them out to risky side ventures.
You keep not addressing that point, or providing concrete monetary values to any of these statements you are making.
Where to start with that. Sure yeah its part of the protocol, but its essentially baking in fiat like inflation.
not only that but its deliberately reducing liquidity, and makes you rely on large exchanges that have bigger stakes.
This basically undermines the point of crypto which is a secure way to quickly exchange value in a peer to peer way.
I don't see the reliance on large exchanges. There are plenty of solo stakers and the protocol gives them the same rate of return as large exchanges. That's an improvement over the economies of scale that large miners typically achieve. People without 32 ETH can use a decentralized staking pool, just like most solo miners use pools.
Total stake is under 15% of ETH so it's not a huge hit to liquidity. The real bottleneck for p2p value exchange is transaction rates, and on that front Ethereum is coming along quite well. If it were only doing ETH payments, it would be capable of 700 tx/sec today on chain. It actually does fewer since many of its transactions are more complex, but rollups multiply that significantly, and upcoming scaling improvements should get them to 100K tx/sec within the next several years, while still maintaining full trustlessness.
This will not solve human moral turpitude that leverages technology to self-enrich at the expense of others.