With consciousness, it's about experiencing sensations, what things feel like from the inside, not about any behaviour on the outside.
With consciousness, it's about experiencing sensations, what things feel like from the inside, not about any behaviour on the outside.
A magnet is the cause/source/reason for/generator of/<insert verb> of a magnetic field. If you put a test charge in a field you can detect a magnet.
So you argue, no simulation of a magnet produces a magnetic field. I assume you mean that you can produce data which would characterize a field were the real world in the state that you simulated.
Then you say a simulated mind doesn't produce consciousness because consciousness is internal not external. Simulating a mind and interacting with it is just behavior checks.
This doesn't make sense then. With magnets you say, "there needs to be a physical field present." But with minds you say, "there needs to be undetectable internal experiences, just reporting and observing behavior isn't consciousness"
This is a dis-analogy.
How do we know that?