Well, thats your view. It begs the question: do you exclude yourself from that, and if so, why are you here?
"No better no worse" implies there is no qualitative difference between them "they're all the same" -again, I think thats an over reach. They have differences. Of course, all finches are finches. But they differ by niche, and so differ by beak, and plumage. Likewise, forums are better or worse for a different point of view, or criterion.
I like HN. I'm not really saying anything else.
I agree HN has a bad side: the tendency of people to simply refute any stated view because they like being contrarian, and because they assume they know something in a field. It's maybe a corollary of Gell-Mann disease. (btw what you did is not this, you just said something else contrarian)