Except all his argument are by proxy.
Is it not true that "the JVM assumes you want classes, single dispatch, inheritance, and primitives. It assumes you don't need 32-bit unsigned math." ?
Is it not true that "adding new bytecodes increases the complexity of VM? That to add "all possible languages a VM needs to support a multitude of calling conventions: tail calls, optional arguments, rest arguments, keyed arguments, overloaded methods, and so on" ?
Is it not true that "jvm specifies a class file format, a concurrency model (in the case of the JVM threads with shared state), class initialization, and a bunch of other stuff that nails down semantic choices." ?
Those are the actual "assertions" made by Dart paper. Which of those facts about jvm Nutter actually countered?