DC sues Amazon for ‘stealing’ $60M in tips from Flex drivers
theverge.com
theverge.com
It could also be interpreted as Amazon "topping up" workers who didn't earn sufficient tips.
In other words, the victims in this specific case are consumers, not Flex Drivers. (Yes, this is pedantic and splitting hairs, but that’s the way the law works.)
* Driver's get $1 per delivery, plus tips.
* Drivers get a guaranteed weekly take-home of $300, provided they work 30 hours.
* Consumers are allowed to give tips to the driver through the app, and '100% goes to the drivers'.
But... Here's the catch. A typical driver does say 100 deliveries and gets $100 of tips in a week. So their take-home (which would be $200) gets increased to $300 by the guarantee.
Now... Who lost out? Where is the fraud? It's unclear... The driver still got everything he was promised. The tips given by the consumer really did end up in the drivers pocket...
But if a consumer is extra generous and gives an extra $50 tip, the driver gets nothing extra - since his total take-home would still be under $300, so would still be topped up to $300 by the company. So effectively the company received the extra generosity. Which isn't what the consumer intended.
Classic restaurant example:. "I saw that table gave you a 1 cent tip, so I'm going to tip you double".
It's more of a social problem than a mathematical one. Either it's okay to reward someone inversely based on their past successes, or it isn't. "Do the best you can, and I'll pay the rest" is exactly that.
The issue is whether Amazon was deceiving consumers, not whether this practice would otherwise be illegal.
I don't trust anything that looks like a faceless megacorp pretending to be social and altruistic.