And why not? It's a huge support burden to do otherwise. You can say "we told you that you'd be locked out" and not even confirm to the user that an account exists with that user ID, but then half of the users who get locked out will complain about it on social media.
You can only really enforce 2FA if your site has to do with money or similar.
I have heard stories of people not being let in and having to contact friends who work at Facebook and have access to the internal support queue. I know my friend had to do something similar at Google and have a friend make a internal support ticket when they were locked out of a gmail account. That experience with Instagram is the reason I moved away from using DUO for everything to Aegis where I can copy a password encrypted backup of my 2FA secret keys like I would any file. I am grateful I learned that lesson by losing 2FA to a single account.