>There is no way to know that a specific OAuth call is made by a specific desktop client so the whole concept of a client secret is incoherent.
What makes you think you can’t issue per-Client, client secrets at install time?
And aside from the authorize call itself, every other OAuth2 call is authenticated to a user and client via the grant type used.
>PKCE… overkill… you’re on a mobile platform in which case you can used authenticated https URLs that get captured by your native app.
It’s explicitly because you cant guarantee that another app hasn’t hooked into your URLs that PKCE exists.