Will they agree to keep selling at that price for as long as we want to buy, or will they only do it until they drive competition out of business, and then jack the prices up, counting on high barriers of entry from keeping new competition out?
Will they agree to keep selling at that price for as long as we want to buy, or will they only do it until they drive competition out of business, and then jack the prices up, counting on high barriers of entry from keeping new competition out?
Subsidizing stationary inputs (like roads, power, and pollution sinks) or stuff that's expensive to move (steel, coal, trained workers) is a way to force a country to industrialize. Subsidizing easily exported inputs (like rare earths) is less effective, as it just ends up in your competitors' final products.
Bottom line: The rare earth story only partially supports your point. That said, the lead time for a new mine is 5+ years, and solar manufacturing lead times may be much lower (and thus barriers to entry also lower).
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/11/17/business/global/prices-of-... [2] http://www.metal-pages.com/metalprices/cerium/ [3] http://www.metal-pages.com/metalprices/terbium/
Also, can you find any examples where the strategy you describe has actually worked?
If not, the latter one, since that's how this stuff has always worked. Just smart business for them.