How hard would it be to spin-off TikTok USA into a separate entity?
How hard would it be to spin-off TikTok USA into a separate entity?
Anyone aggrieved by this would move on to the next social fad and forget that TikTok even exists as quickly as they forgot #kony2012 three months later.
And my guess is that they're not exactly enthusiastic participants in the electoral system anyway.
Gen Z voters were the driving force giving the Democrats the best midterm results in decades.
> Snapchat (96%) , TikTok( 91%), Youtube (87%), and Instagram (83%) are the top three social media platforms used by Gen Z, according to a new study done by National Research Group.
For comparison banning TikTok would have a wider impact on Gen Z than banning them from YouTube.
(edited to add: I don't support banning TikTok. This is actually a free speech issue. I didn't like it when Trump did it by executive fiat and I don't like it now. If the content there is truly that corrosive, implement punitive measures short of a full ban. The bar has to be much higher than "I don't like it" for the government to fully censor something.)
Also banning TikTok might set off a Cold War of banning each other’s apps and I have to think we would lose more in that scenario.
Amazon is doing decently there currently.
Google was banned after they decided to stop censoring searches.
Facebook was banned after they refused to provide the government the identities of protestors in Urumqi.
Google cancelled Dragonfly after outcry from their employees.
Anyway, if Google and Facebook need to follow censorship laws in China, then maybe TikTok needs to follow not-being-based-in-China laws in the US. After all, they can't just decide not to follow the laws.
https://www.thatsmags.com/china/post/32153/this-day-in-histo...
Dragonfly was stopped after pressure from Americans, both civil and political pressure.
> In 2018, media reports that Google was working on a prototype for another censored Chinese search engine surfaced, which was met with backlash from some Google employees. The development, called ‘Project Dragonfly,’ was shortly after suspended, according to The Intercept.
The US government did not force Google to stop Dragonfly.
If China can enforce a censorship policy, America can enforce a consistent not-based-in-China policy.
America can do anything it wants, I just wanted to dispute the idea that it would be a reciprocal action. I think it would be a pretty big uncalled for escalation.
That is patently untrue. China's enforcement of its GFW ban list (which is still an unpublished state secret) has been very focused at specific companies, especially in the earlier days when they didn't just ban everything. CNN, for example, was on the s-list for many years due to Tiananmen Square (ironically, being unblocked later while NyTimes would get on the s-list for publish an at article about Xi's family wealth).
China's censorship policies (again an unpublished state secret) are anything but consistent. They are mostly applied for personal retribution (don't publish articles about the leader's family financial assets) or business advantages (don't let in competitors that would challenge domestic champions).
"They weren't following the law"
The law:
"You have to give a chinese company all your technology and 51 percent ownership"
China is a flat out enemy of the United States. We should treat TikTok as an arm of that enemy as a result of how China demands state control over every company operating in the country.
https://asia.nikkei.com/Spotlight/Caixin/In-Depth-How-SoftBa...
No, the kids will not throw a temper tantrum and vote for $THE_OTHER_GUY because you blocked their access to an app. The kids, in fact, stand for more than just politics-as-sports.