I don't think you even really believe that yourself.
For the purposes of my education and socialisation to HN.
My terse response was "no, because calculators are correct all the time whereas GPT is incorrect a lot of time". So, that reasoning can't be used. Need a different one.
So we conclude, no that's not a good analogy.
That's what you mean by curious debate? Bizarre!
P.s. this is why it's a good analogy you've learnt something about calculators from thinking about the analogy as well as chatGPT
My general approach to discussion is to assume the most generous interpretation of a post.
But you do you.