>We also consider who is sharing the reported information and whether or not they have the consent of the person it belongs to. We do this because we know that there are times when people may want some forms of their personal information to be shared publicly.
... and...
>If the reported information was shared somewhere else before it was shared on Twitter, e.g., someone sharing their personal phone number on their own publicly accessible website, we may not treat this information as private, as the owner has made it publicly available.
... and especially...
>We also factor in the intent of the person sharing the information.
[1]https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/personal-info...
. . .
> live location information, including information shared on Twitter directly or links to 3rd-party URL(s) of travel routes, actual physical location, or other identifying information that would reveal a person’s location, regardless if this information is publicly available;
This bullet point has none of the caveats that you are hinging your defense of their policy on.
I don't know how else to tell you that a concert isn't private information.
“the owner has made it publicly available” also describes Elon’s ADS-B receiver, incidentally. It broadcasts to the public.
More explicitly, legally speaking, "the following types of private information" means "the following list of things, which we are calling private information", not "the following list of things, when they are considered as private information (defined elsewhere)".
>What is not a violation of this policy?
>sharing information that is publicly available elsewhere, in a non-abusive manner (with the exception of live location information)
"I'm at [venue] seeing [performer]!" is non-abusive, and the information is available through advertising for the show, signage on the venue itself, the venue's website, the venue's social media profiles, the ticketing company's website, the artist's website, the artist's social media profiles, the promoter's social media pages, media stories, the list goes on.
It's hastily written, yes, but in the context of the broader happenings at Twitter, and what people generally use it for (eg, musicians are gonna want to tell people where they are, and they're gonna want people to tell other people they saw them, and the venue is gonna want the promotion, etc.), this is pretty obvious.
Edit: Oh, look! Twitter themselves have specifically supported my read of this[1]:
>Content that shares location information related to a public engagement or event, such as a concert or political event, is also permitted.
[1]https://twitter.com/TwitterSafety/status/1603165967453868032
re: your edit; find that statement in the "full policy" link at the end of the thread. It's not documented there.
Yup! That's why I even mentioned that it was clearly hastily written in an earlier comment. For what it's worth, I think I share your sentiment, re: Musk/freedom of speech. It's hastily written because it's reactionary and, assuming Musk/Twitter can ever actually get their house in order, I'd anticipate that it will be more clearly written into the terms over time. But in spite of it not being written clearly...
>re: your edit; find that statement in the "full policy" link at the end of the thread. It's not documented there.
... I've still managed to demonstrate in this comment chain that I was able to understand the intent of the poorly-written "full policy" link, based on my assertion yesterday followed by the confirmation Tweet that I shared this morning. And I'm fairly certain you did, too.
This comment chain is feeling incredibly cyclical, so I'm gonna bounce.