Perhaps good trade-off would have been that non-ASCII is allowed only in country code TLDs, with these country operators limiting to only characters in their own alphabet.
E.g. for Finland .fi could do fine with just allowing ASCII + ä, ö, å.
How would that be represented on the wire? I don’t think restricting it in that way makes sense.
Wire format could be the same. But to prevent eg. homoglyph attacks the principle on what non-Unicode characters are allowed would be 'default deny'.
Oh, of course. I retract my previous objection, brain fart on my part.
But I don't think all of them do that. What if browsers, etc. were updated so that IDNs under TLDs where that rule isn't strictly enforced were always rendered in punycode?
Firefox already does this, with some improvements.