You're probably getting downvoted for the first phrase - there does seem to be some genetic component, albeit it's not clear how important it really is.
I agree with everything else you said.
I agree with everything else you said.
Appetite regulation would be one, but that wouldn't explain studies in which food intake is strictly controlled. Metabolism regulation, insulin/glucagon regulation, intestinal flora, digestive efficiency, and other factors would certainly affect overall body mass.
And issues such as thyroid function do directly affect metabolism.